Replies

Dave wrote:

These, on the other hand, are fantastic.

Like a vast predatory bird.

1 user thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle

They do look a bit ropey. Which is my general reaction to most McFarlane stuff, to be honest. I noticed they’re doing a TMNT line soon and honestly, given the amount of companies with a TMNT license you’d be forgiven for thinking it had entered the public domain.

Meanwhile, I’ve been politely ignoring the Jada SF figures but, for some reason, seeing Balrog at NYCC has piqued my interest in the line. Which is odd, given I have no special affection for Balrog, but he looks really cool. I might pick up one of the earlier releases (maybe Vega, I’ve always loved his design).

1 user thanked author for this post.

Dave

Dave wrote:

You can’t fool us, that’s just Moon Knight in a hat.

That’s a cool figure though, very striking looking.

Ha, it is a bit, isn’t it.

I would not have guessed that of all the Western characters, Phantom Rider would get a figure first. I figured it’d have been Rawhide Kid, if anyone.

4 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, lorcan_nagle, lorcan_nagle, Dave

::hits the gong of celebration::

::chokes on a resulting cloud of dust::

Phantom Rider Marvel Legend figure! Finally a Western character gets an ML after over 20 years!

He’s right there next to popular character Green Dude.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Todd, lorcan_nagle

I’ve been steaming through these Avengers epic collections. Some thoughts, broken down by writer rather than volume.

Roy Thomas

It’s weird, the quality of his work is on a bell curve. He starts out as a Stan Lee tribute act (which isn’t a terrible thing); then develops his own style a bit, matures and gives us things like the Vision and the Yellow-Jacket story (which has issues, but you wouldn’t have seen Stan do it); and then absolute power goes to his head and he’s putting out over-written self-indulgent dreck.

Steve Englehart

This is a nice change of pace. I really like the addition of Swordsman and Mantis to the team early on, with Swordsman’s redemption being surprisingly good. It is a bit weird that Mantis is with the team, full participating and yet they keep saying “you’re just the Swordsman’s girlfriend, not an actual Avenger”. They only make her a full member when she leaves. The series does start to get bogged down in complicated lore and stories though. The Celestial Madonna story drags on waaaay too long. It involves at least three multi-part stories fighting Kang, which – even as a Kang fan – is too much. The triple hit of Englehart a) having Kang fight against his future self Rama-Tut (which is also his earlier identity) and also turn out to be Immortus b) delving into the background of the Vision and making him the original Human Torch repurposed and c) going through the backstory of Mantis, all threaded together, is rough going. Mantis’s backstory is so complicated that it isn’t worth it. It’s so complicated that, if you didn’t know, you’d swear it was a later writer (like John Byrne) retconning someone else’s earlier work, but it’s seemingly all planned out by Englehart that you get one backstory for her, which is later contradicted at length and then comprehensively explained at ever great length. An explanation that also requires explaining the history of the Kree empire and its enmity with the Skrulls. And after all that, whatever good bits the Celestial Madonna story might have had along the way, it’s impossible to get past the fact that Mantis ends up marrying a guy she’s known for ten minutes, who is possessing the corpse of her ex-boyfriend and, crucially, is a tree.

Englehart does a bit of a reset after that and it’s a nice clean slate with interesting changes. Beast is brought in, to essentially pick up and finish off storylines from his solo series (I didn’t realise before that was why he was brought into the Avengers) and also sees the introduction of Moondragon, which is less successful. She just doesn’t really do enough and is ultimately used to come up with a reason to take Thor out of the book. This era has the story about Kang invading the 19th Century, forcing Hawkeye, Thor and Moondragon to team up with some of Marvel’s Western heroes, which is something I’ve wanted to read for ages. Shame it’s not very good. Just not very much happens in it, really. Kang’s plan seems to be just having a building and, off panel, hypnotising people to mine uranium. It needed more going on. Lovely George Perez art though. Perez is a highlight through much of these volumes. He’s so good that even Vince Colletta inking him doesn’t ruin his art.

This latter Englehart period also has the Serpent Crown story with the Squadron Supreme, which is a lot of fun. That introduces Hellcat (with some very shonky plotting of “oh, look, The Cat/Tigra’s old costume happens to be in the storehouse of this evil company we’re infiltrating. I’ll take it”) and it’s clear that Englehart plans to use her on the team.

Unfortunately his end runs messily. As he tells it, he was fired because Gerry Conway, then editor, wanted to write Avengers himself. As Conway tells it, Englehart kept missing his deadlines. It’s probably a bit of both, I think. Certainly it’s not a good look that #150, which promises to be a status quo changing anniversary issue basically peters out after about 10 pages and becomes a reprint of #16. When the story is picked up again the next issue, you can feel the abrupt change of direction as Conway takes over from Englehart’s plot. Yellowjacket walks out of the meeting, saying he doesn’t want to be an Avenger, then suddenly walks back in and goes “uh, I arbitrarily changed my mind!”. Hellcat is dead set on joining the team, but then Moondragon suddenly demands that they go off together to train instead and Patsy agrees (head canon: Heather is mind controlling her, but jeez, it does not read smoothly). It’s not a pretty transition. Still, having muscled his way on to the book, Conway’s got to have some bold ideas, right?

Gerry Conway

Not so much. After the series had promised an exciting shake up of the team, Conway ends up with a line-up of basically all the same people who were there before. He then adds in Wonder Man, brought back from the dead with no real explanation (yet). I’ve no problem with Wonder Man generally, but I do not understand the obsession 70s Avengers writers had with him. The most interesting thing about him was that he died. I think we probably would have all been better off if the Vision’s brain patterns hadn’t been based on him, because when Wonder Man comes back, it just sets up the Vision going back into the same “I’m not a real man, only a machine” stuff he’s been through several times already.

I only read Conway’s run in the last week or so and Wonder Man coming back is literally the only thing I can remember from it. So let’s move on to…

Jim Shooter

Who fills in for Conway a few times before taking over (ironically). I’m not all the way through his run yet. I’m a few issues into the Korvac Saga (which I’ve read before). Shooter’s issues are quite strange, and they remind me of his time as EiC, in that there’s a strange duality to it. As EiC he made Marvel less dysfunctional than it had been in ages, perhaps ever. Loads of seminal series and runs occurred in his tenure. And yet he was also hated by a lot of his staff and accused of ruining titles with stupid suggestions (eg wanting to kill off Shang-Chi). As Avengers writer, the book is pretty damn good. The characters are sharply written, the stories are good and yet… so far they’ve faced three villains and they’re all prety much the same. First is Graviton, an ordinary man who gains incredible power, tries to force a woman to love him and then seemingly dies. Then they face Count Nefaria, an ordinary man who gains incredible power and then seemingly dies (while, as an aside, grabbing a random woman to possibly take with him). And then there’s Korvac, a weird cyborg guy who somehow gains incredible, almost godlike powers and uses them to kidnap a woman to make her his wife and then seemingly dies.  It’s all a bit repetitive. If you’re being charitable, you could say Shooter’s working with recurrent themes and escalating them in stakes, but it does just kinda feel like he’s got the one idea and is rehashing it in quick succession. And like Chris Claremont, it really feels like you’re reading about his own kinks and desire relationship dynamics in how the villains treat women. There’s just bad vibes to it.

4 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Sean Robinson, njerry, lorcan_nagle

After three (four?) years, I’ve given up on More4 bringing over the final season of The Good Fight and decided to watch it through other means. I remember s5 getting a bit too weird for its own good (all the stuff with community courts) and so my expectations for s6 weren’t that high. But it’s great! Possibly the best the show has been? I don’t know, it’s so long since I’ve seen the earlier seasons.

One of the problems the show’s had over the years is losing cast members between seasons and having to adjust. John Larroquette disappearing after season 4 was a notable one. And that’s true here. The end of s5 spend some time setting up Wanda Sykes as the new name partner in the law firm, only for her to be absent here, written out with a passing line. But! Instead of Wanda Sykes, they brought in Andre Braugher! He’s on top form here as Ri’chard, a bombastic, ostentatiously religious lawyer with an ulterior motive, installed as the new name partner of the firm by the other law firm that owns the main one on the show (it’s complicated).

I’d forgotten over the past few years how much I liked just getting to see some of the other members of the cast, like Marissa and Jay. And Diane, of course. Return appearances for Elsbeth and Eli Gold – whose first shot is him in a lift, supposedly talking on the phone but clearly addressing the audience directly and berating use for our politics and “oh what, you’ve never heard me swear before?” – are fun too.

The weird element of it though is that it’s very political and from 2022, so it’s in that strange zone of being out of date but not entirely dated, you know? It’s talking about things that are still issues, but with a foresight for what has really been inevitable. It’s like watching footage of someone who is approaching a very slow speed car crash and is entirely aware of it.

1 user thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle

Dave wrote:

I’m not an expert in this area,

I kinda am. I’ve been deep in TF fandom for over 20 years.

Dave wrote:

mainly with the Marvel UK stuff

The complaints are about the poor scans of Marvel UK material partially yes – certainly that’s where the crumpled pages come into it and questions about ordering and integration with the US material and that many covers haven’t been included (some of which were used in the Kickstarter promotion). This isn’t an insignificant element, given the set was sold to many on the appeal of having the UK material mixed in with the US for the first time (and it warrants as much care as the US stuff whichever way you look at it). The original files are available – Titan used them, Marvel or Panini will own them. But the complaints are also about the low quality scans of Marvel US, the poor OCR that hasn’t been corrected, the newly poor scans of G2, the lacking colour restoration and the poor attempts at “error correction” that, much like with IDW’s trades, focus on things that aren’t errors, such as this:

Soundwave in his correct, original Marvel US colour scheme with an original art error of him having a face, newly “corrected” to:

Soundwave in his animated series colour scheme with his “correct” face bodged over the original.

Dave wrote:

it also seems like Skybound were upfront initially that it would be the IDW/Hachette files that were used and that it was a reprint project rather than a restoration/remastering, which would obviously be a different deal.

They were not upfront about it at all. They actively avoided engaging with anyone asking about it or eventually pointing this out and casually mentioned it in passing on a Near Mint Condition stream.

Meanwhile the Kickstarter page was throwing around phrasing like “magnificent” “premium hardcover”, and “the ultimate reading experience”. I mean to me it’s not the “ultimate reading experience” if it’s objectively worse than the original monthlies and previous publisher’s tpbs.

The Kickstarter buries in its FAQ only

Have any of the files used for these compendiums been remastered?

We’ve worked with Hasbro to source the available files.

Which says nothing. The main Kickstarter page talks more about spot gloss than it does the source material. People who approached Skybound to offer help with making new, better scans (especially of the UK material) such as JP Bove (the colourist for the Hachette collections of the originally black and white Marvel UK material) were ignored (and in Bove’s case, not even credited for his previous work). And remember, after the funding ending, they had $4m to work with. And people were offering these scans freely and considering they knew the stuff they had to work with was crumpled, off colour etc, was bold.

Dave wrote:

So it doesn’t seem like people are really being fooled into buying something they didn’t expect,

Literally a string of Kickstarter comments linked above (as well as posts on social media and other forums) say otherwise. Never mind the fact they used Kickstarter FOMO on the combined US/UK versions (whereas the mass market paperbacks will only have them separately) to get people to pre-order them sight unseen.

Dave wrote:

The loudest complaining voices seem to be from those who chose not to stump up for the set and want to feel good about their decision.

I was considering getting this set, or the paperback versions, when it was announced. I am very much in the market for OHC of the complete Marvel US and UK. It was only because I dug into interviews and waited for previews of the paperbacks (thereby missing the Kickstarter) that I was able to make an informed decision and thankfully dodged a bullet. So yeah, there’s definitely some gloating on my part here, but also mainly disgust that Skybound would rake in $4m for this “premium” project and not give it the effort it deserved.

Dave wrote:

Again, this is just from observing what is being said by people more expert than me in this area.

Yes, hello again, this is me, a people more expert than you in this area. Many people are justifiably pissed off, or at least disappointed at being duped into buying an “ultimate” collection of Transformers that is severely lacking, especially as this isn’t the first time for a lot of us. IDW did the same thing when they immediately started their second run of reprint trades after the first ones, where they hadn’t bothered to negotiate the use of Circuit Breaker etc with Marvel, so just skipped those issues. The idea that this was a once in a life time, limited premium product that you absolutely had to Kickstart or miss out on was not insignificant to attracting attention (and they hadn’t solicited or listed the paperback UK compendiums before the Kickstarter was launched IIRC). And yet, it’s the same old stuff served up in a new hat and a premium price. I get Vik’s attitude of “well at least I have it” but even on that front, the paperbacks will be across the next year or so, with all the same material in the same poor quality for a fraction of the price. This is Lyle Lanley levels of hucksterism from Skybound and no-one should be making excuses for it.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson, Todd, lorcan_nagle

Dave wrote:

when I know there aren’t any available original files

There are absolutely original files available. Titan used them. Marvel used them for their five trades of GI Joe. IDW and Skybound just chose not to use them with Skybound saying they’re “not available”. Given that Marvel have been able to use original files for reprint editions of old licensed series like Conan, Rom, Micronauts, Godzilla and more, I find it hard to believe the only files they didn’t hold onto were Transformers and GI Joe issue 51 onwards. Clearly IDW and Skybound didn’t want to pay Marvel’s price and are trying to make it sound like they don’t exist.

Dave wrote:

As for leaving in typos from the original comics

These aren’t typos from the original comics though. They’re errors introduced from the terrible OCR IDW did when doing their (low res) scans of the original series, that they didn’t bother to proofread and correct. This isn’t someone in the 80s forgetting the odd letter or mispelling something, it’s “Goldbuggy” being bastardised into “Goldbussy” because their OCR sucks and no-one could be arsed to correct it, despite these being known errors for over a decade now and Skybound having a crowd-funded budget of over $4m to work with.

If you want to buy cheaply produced crap, by all means, fill your boots and justify it any way you want. But to claim this isn’t just a lazy cash-grab by Skybound is disingenuous.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, paul f, lorcan_nagle

Dave wrote:

Patricia Routledge has kicked the bouquet.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/czdjegvjz3do.amp

Everyone will likely, fairly, be talking about Keeping Up Appearances, but I remember quite liking Hetty Wainthrope Investigates back in the day. Zero clue if that holds up. I should check some time.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

[Martin Smith]

I think you’re letting them off far too lightly. And also:

Vikram wrote:

I spent a stupid amount of money on it

Vikram wrote:

only viable option for me to acquire this collection in a timely manner and for a reasonable price

which is it? A stupid amount of money or a reasonable price? If you just wanted the series to read as a PDF, you’d genuinely be better off with pirated scans, because there are much better quality ones out there. And this isn’t your only option for physical. The Titan trades are still out there, as are the IDW ones (which admittedly don’t do all the UK material) and the Hachette partwork. And they’d probably cost less to get a set of than the upper tiers of this kickstarter.

Vikram wrote:

high end hardcover

Is it really a “high end” hardcover, if they haven’t put in the effort on actually restoring the contents (or indeed making a contents page, according to the PDF)? It’s like making an expensive steelbook UHD blu-ray release of a movie but only using a 4th generation VHS dub of it.

Your “well at least I’ve got it in some manner” attitude has absolutely been taken advantage of by Skybound here.

 

• This reply was modified 1 week, 2 days ago by Martin Smith.

1 user thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle

Dave wrote:

And like a lot of business models they’re now increasingly trying to push people on to a subscription model where you don’t ever really own anything but pay a monthly fee to use it.

Microsoft are already into the ratchet up the price phase, which I think they’ve gone to too quickly to pull off.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Ben

They were kinda taking the piss a bit with PS1 games being £50 though. They were just matching the average price of cartridge games (and to be fair, Sega did the same with the Saturn) because they could get away with it (and for the perception of value), even though the manufacturing cost of a CD game is a tiny fraction of a cartridge game. Prices stayed steady for so long simply because there was an awful lot of profit margin that could be sacrificed through the mid-90s to recent past.

Arjan Dirkse wrote:

Christian wrote:

Sounds like Bernie Sanders to me!

He’s going to be 87 in 2028 ;)

Far too young. Get these kids out of politics, dagnabbit!

2 users thanked author for this post.

Christian, Todd

Says a lot that when the film industry created its own fake “star” that it has complete control over they made a teenage white girl.

2 users thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle, Todd

Yeah, I think resolution on TVs has topped out now. The real draw is an interface that won’t make you want to throw the remote into the screen when trying to do something simple. I was round a friend’s house recently and we were trying to access the basic RF input (to use an N64). Absolute hell. The option to scan for frequencies was incredibly hard to find but even then, getting to the analogue channels required going to the digital ones first, and every time we went to those, it started with BBC Three (for some reason) which would immediately move us into the iPlayer app.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Ben

lorcan_nagle wrote:

And because there’s a two term-limit, the current president, Yoda Michael D Higgins can’t run again.

What was Higgins’s deal before he was President?

1 user thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle

[Martin Smith]

Skybound have sent out backer PDFs for their Transformers Compendium Kickstarter that was blatantly just using the IDW “remasters” and yet somehow got $4m or so in funding. And, er, it’s not going down well.

I’m not even out of issue one and have found multiple typos. These are apparently known mistakes from previous reprints that several prominent online fans could have cited for you. Or just a person with eyes actually reading the comics. Not good enough Skybound.

Skybound’s response to initial displeasure.

Greetings Backers,

We appreciate all the feedback on THE TRANSFORMERS CompendiumPDFs and wanted want to make sure we addressed some backer notes.
Skybound is committed to delivering the highest quality editions with our TRANSFORMERS compendiums.

The files were primarily sourced from Hachette’s Partworks editions, as well as some additional sources in the TF community. We made hundreds of additional corrections, with the primary goal of keeping the material as close to how it was originally published, while correcting art, colors, and lettering to fix incorrectly colored characters, typos, broken balloons, and lettering, etc.

While that means there will be some visible imperfections such as creases, color fading, or scan artifacts as part of the archival material itself, we are confident these TRANSFORMERS compendiums will deliver the same reading experience as you’ve come to expect from us.

Thank you for your questions and we look forward to you holding the final hardcovers in your hands!

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/skyboundent/transformers-compendium-set/posts/4494414/comments

I was expect a once in a lifetime physical unified TF experience.
I didn’t back at $600USD (over $900AUD) for essentially bootleg scans I could’ve accquired elsewhere online.
Please take the time to do it right before printing the physical versions, this is what we supported you to do.

Looking at the scans for Burning Sky Part Two, and it’s like somebody actively crumpled the comic up before scanning. Yikes.

Yall arent going to do the right thing and fix this garbage or you would have already done it. You have FOUR POINT SIX MILLION and you’re creating mistakes.

Straight up, how do i get my money back?

I mean, come on, the creases are one thing, but whoever scanned the G2 #1 gatefold could have at least laid it properly flat on the scanner…

While it absolutely sucks that people got ripped off for this, as someone who a) saw this coming and b) doesn’t like Skybound, I’m feeling a lot of schadenfreude from this. I really hope it has some impact on the company.

• This reply was modified 1 week, 6 days ago by Martin Smith.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Ben, lorcan_nagle

EA is now owned by Saudi Arabia and Jared Kushner, via leveraged buy out. So expect a lot of cost-cutting, layoffs, studio closures and more Saudi teams in Not-FIFA.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

I watched famously unprofitable movie Men In Black last night. I’ve not seen it since about 1999 and I was surprised just how much of it I remembered quite clearly. And yet, I didn’t think it was amazing. It was fine, but the bits I mainly enjoyed were the bits I so clearly remembered (J’s interview process). Still, good on Columbia for rolling with the totally real loss it made and giving it three more tries in the vain hope one would make them some money.

I’m probably not going to watch the second one (I remember it not being good and being disappointed at the time that it backtracked on Linda Fiorentino being J’s new partner) but maybe 3. And I might try the animated series too. Actually, I suppose that having K in it was the death knell for L being in the film sequel.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Todd

[Martin Smith]

I finished off Valkyrie Profile 2 Silmeria last night, which took me just shy of two months. Or more accurately about 16 years. I bought it in 08 or 09, got partway in and dropped it for something else, as was my style at the time. I went to replay it a few years ago as a one of my “replay an old games before Christmas” deals, but played a few hours on like the 17th December and (correctly!) realised I’d never get through it all in time.

Because this is a long game – I racked up about 70+ hours I think (that’s with skipping some of the optional dungeons in the third quarter of the game and not bothering with the end-game super levelling dungeon) – and it’s not one that particularly respects your time either. The game is split into six chapters, but not very evenly. Chapter six took me a few days. Chapter four took an evening. Chapter three took about four weeks. That was partially because, despite doing the optional dungeons in that too, I hit a difficultly spike and had to spend a few evenings levelling up by just grinding a replayable boss fight, but it is also just disproportionately long and almost entirely devoid of any story content to pull you through that section.

One of the strengths and weaknesses of the game is its einherjar characters (I should say, it’s all very loosely based on Norse myth). These are essentially just filler characters to bulk out your party. Your first thought might be to ignore them, which would be fair, but the game dicks you around with taking away all your main party characters at various points, so they’re essential to have filling those gaps and as replacements for dead characters you can’t revive when in a dungeon. So keeping them all levelled up enough to step in is a chore (the game doesn’t give you an XP share type power until relatively late and even then it’s expensive to claim permanently). By the last chapter, I’d settled on a core party of four characters, three of whom were einherjar, and focusing on just them did speed things up and meant they levelled up at a degree that kept them powerful enough to deal with almost everything pretty easily.

Partially this was from utilising the other benefit of the einherjar. Each one has a “release level” which is the point at which you can bin them off from the party, they get properly reincarnated to go off and live new lives (you can go and find them in the towns and dungeons and talk to them). When they go you get stat boosting items and the stuff you get is relative to how much higher the einherjar’s level is than the release level and what gear they’ve got equipped (which goes with them). So before the final dungeon I released all my einherjar bar the three in my core party, equipped with all the second best armour that I hadn’t sold, and got absolutely tonnes of stat boosts that I concentrated on those core four. So even the penultimate boss proved no problem (the final one was trickier because the game decides that only one character can cause any real damage to him, which is a hindrance).

It’s an interesting twist on the Pokemon format, in a way, incentivising you to use all the characters but also to let them go. The other impressive thing about the einherjar is the story telling with them. They don’t participate in the main story, they don’t get to appear in cut-scenes or anything. But they all have text back stories, detailing their lives and these are mostly interconnected, covering several wars and conflicts and fallen empires across a few hundred years. The text summaries though aren’t the full story and you get a fun insight into that when you have certain pairings of characters in your party. For instance, the archer Lylia is said to be the queen of a city-state who was kidnapped and missing for six years. When she was finally found and returned home, she committed suicide. Her captor was the mage Woltar, who you can also get, who is described as a reclusive dark mage who kidnapped Queen Lylia and then was killed by the state’s army when she was discovered. But put Lylia and Woltar together in your party and you will sometimes get the following exchange at the start of a battle.

Lylia: I prayed a thousand times that we might one day be reunited.
Woltar: I too, my love. We must thank the fickleness of fate.

Yes, they were really lovers. When you talk to Lylia after she’s reincarnated, she reveals that her marriage to the king was an arranged thing, she was 16, he was in his 60s, so she escaped and met Woltar and they had a baby (who is also an einherjar). It’s a really clever bit of world building and there’s loads of examples of it. Unfortunately, it’s complicated by how you get the einherjar. You get them when you find sparkly weapons out in the world but (most of the time) the einherjar you get from that is one of two or three, with a set percentage chance of which you get. Some characters, according to guides, only have a 10% chance of appearing. I suspect this is to encourage replays (which is bold, of a game this big), but the chances of getting all the characters that have connections to each other is really slim.

All that aside, the game is, at it’s core, pretty fun. It’s mostly in a 2d side-scrolling platformy type thing – think Zelda 2 – but when you start combat you move into a 3d arena. You can move your characters freely, either as a group or your split them up for tactical stuff like pincers movements (rarely if ever necessary tbh). It’s not real time, as your enemies only move when you move. Your actions are limited by an AP gauge, which also only recharges as you move (or you press a specific recharge button, during which your enemies can move and attack). Actual combat switches to a side perspective again and you trigger each character’s attacks with an assigned face button. The trick is in getting a nice rhythm between the four, so that one attack isn’t missing because of the other. Ideally, you’ll be getting enough hits in within a short enough time that (assuming you don’t just kill the enemy first) you can trigger characters’ special attacks. Or your attack might hit an enemy’s weak point and break part of it off. This can get you new equipment (weapons, armour, accessories) which is cool but also a pain when you find yourself farming a certain type of enemy from a certain angle in hopes of getting a certain accessory that has the right coloured rune you need to equip in order to let you learn a new skill. As with so much of the game, there are lots of complications. But when you get in the zone, as I did in the late game, it really sings.

I’m glad to have finally finished this. I wouldn’t really recommend it (not least because it’s on the PS2) and I’m not sure I’d ever play it again. But if it ever happens to get remastered, I think it’d be worth a look.

• This reply was modified 2 weeks, 1 day ago by Martin Smith.

There’s a petition against those digital ID cards on the UK government website that’s hit nearly 1 million signatures in under a day.

4 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Ben, lorcan_nagle, Todd

paul f wrote:

Martin Smith wrote:

Still, roll on s3 and more celebrity killers. And if they could work in a Good Wife cameo (Eli or Carey ideally, possibly Diane) that’d be nice.

Not Eli, but they just confirmed Marissa Gold will be showing up this season.

:O JUST AS GOOD!

I watched the season finale of Elsbeth s2 today and that is definitely one of the best shows going at the moment. It’s just Columbo for the 2020s – a quirky weirdo solving murders committed by celebrity guest stars – but there’s no shame in that, especially when it’s built such a lovely cast of characters (including Wendell Pierce as the police captain). The finale was especially fun because it sees Elsbeth detained in prison on charges of witness intimidation, amongst loads of the killers from previous episodes (whose inmate numbers are, handily, their episode numbers) and solving the further murder of one of them. And there’s a great musical sequence too.

There’s a moment in it where it’s talking about making knives from uncooked ramen noodles and it does a little “this is real” graphic, which is the closest the show has ever felt to the Good Fight. It’s kinda weird to think really that they both came from the same root show, like both hard hitting drama Lou Grant and sitcom Rhoda both coming from The Mary Tyler Moore Show.

Still, roll on s3 and more celebrity killers. And if they could work in a Good Wife cameo (Eli or Carey ideally, possibly Diane) that’d be nice.

Well, that’s finally tipped me over into needing to get a PS5.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Ben, Dave

I’ve finished Avengers Epic Collection v5 which means I have now finally read the Kree Skrull War. I’ve read various stories related to it (Operation Galactic Storm, Avengers Forever) over the years and it’s this foundational, keystone story to so much MU lore and man it’s not just very good, is it?

Lovely art by Neal Adams, sure, but Roy Thomas’s writing has nosedived in quality since the previous volume. His narration is getting increasingly purple and second person, so he’s essentially directly taunting characters in syntactically abstruse sentences that are just hard to parse for the most part. Maybe it didn’t help I was reading most of this late in the evening. Also, considering he’s a former English teacher, he’s got a terrible understanding of when you should use me rather than I in a sentence (as Stan Lee did before him), which also doesn’t help.

But on top of that the plotting is just crap. The actual Kree Skrull war doesn’t really consist of a war between the Kree and Skrulls, it’s just each taking turns to kidnap people off Earth. There’s an entire digression to involve the Inhumans which adds nothing but over-complication. He tries to pull it all together at the end by having the Supreme Intelligence claim he mentally pushed people into taking their otherwise arbitrary actions, but that does not hang together at all. And it’s not just the plot making sense, the characters act really inconsistently, not just between issues but within the same issue. Hawkeye says he’s run out of Growth Serum (he’s Goliath II at this point, which is a bizarre decision, especially as Hank and Jan were both still on the team when he made it) yet a few panels later, he’s grown a bit (“just enough left in him for a few minutes growth” or something). An issue later he’s saying he made the decision to stop using it. In one issue, the team splits up, half to go with Triton to rescue Black Bolt in San Francisco, the other half to go to space to rescue Quicksilver, Wanda and Captain Marvel. Yet the latter team hang around fighting mandroids and then they’re just “actually, let’s go save Black Bolt” so meet up with the others at the Great Refuge. And I think that’s just Thomas not managing to understand and convey the plot Adams has drawn really. It seems to me the intention was “we’ll stay here hold off the Mandroids while you three escape to find Black Bolt and we’ll meet up later” but it’s been twisted into something that makes less sense.

Oh and then there’s Rick summoning loads of Golden Age heroes to fend off Ronan and the Kree which is the ultimate self-indulgence on Thomas’s part. They have no plot significance at all. Rick could have summoned anything as constructs to fill that purpose, or nothing at all. It just bogs the story down by introducing all these old characters (most of whom are passed off as being fictional) who disappear immediately after saying their names. What a waste of time and effort.

So yeah, that was pretty disappointing really.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

When I think of Marvel in the 70s being a mess, I always think of that one issue of Iron Man that just stops at page 14 or so because that’s all they had done before the deadline for the printer.

Sean, the issues that had me despairing at sexism are around #80 or so.

Which also has the debut of Red Wolf, which is handled a bit oddly. They go to all this effort setting up a new hero (who I quite like) and then at the end of the second issue with him have him kill off his heroic identity. I would have had him join the team to be honest. They launched a Red Wolf solo series not long after but it was initially set in the Old West with the first Red Wolf (he was created as a character with a legacy). He got binned off after half a dozen issues to be replaced by a modern Red Wolf who is completely unrelated to the one in Avengers and makes no mention of him. Weird.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Sean Robinson

I’ve embarked on a big Avengers read through thanks to having a big run of epic collections. Over the past year or so, I’ve picked up v5-11 (though I already had 9). Read one issue of v5 and immediately went “I have no memory of this team status quo” so ended up re-reading v4 first. So that means I’ll be going from #57 (first appearance of the Vision) through to #209.

Anyway, I’m halfway through v5 at the moment and I was thinking as I read it “this is a bit sexist. Thomas always finds ways to minimise Wanda and have her end up a damsel in distress.” There’s one moment where she can’t defend herself because her “hex power needs to recharge” or some such nonsense and you don’t get Quicksilver going “hang on, I can’t be quick at the moment, I’ve got a stitch”. Literally the issue after the one that had me thinking that: the Lady Liberators, where Valkyrie brings together Wasp, Medusa, Scarlet Witch and Black Widow to take out the Avengers. It really felt like it was addressing those criticisms I had, while also belittling them. Impressive how it managed to have its cake and eat it too without really making any actual kind of statement or change.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson, Todd, lorcan_nagle

lorcan_nagle wrote:

Out in April:

 

https://www.comicsbeat.com/exclusive-dark-horse-announces-nerd-inferno-the-essential-evan-dorkin

 

You too can own the David Byrne Gets Alzheimers comic srtip.

I don’t think I’ve ever seen that.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, lorcan_nagle, Sean Robinson

[Martin Smith]

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c78n455mj08o

Four arrests after Trump and Epstein images projected on Windsor Castle
Four men have been arrested after images of Donald Trump and convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein were projected on to Windsor Castle on Tuesday, as the US president arrived in the UK for a state visit.
They were arrested on suspicion of “malicious communications following a public stunt in Windsor” and remained in custody, Thames Valley Police said.

It doesn’t say, but I assume this is Led By Donkeys again.

• This reply was modified 3 weeks, 4 days ago by Martin Smith.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Uncle Retrospective

I think the biggest change is Ego bailing, relatively last minute, which leaves the show without any black female cast members. Now, you can say that’s because Ego’s exit wasn’t expected, but it’s moreso on the show for only having one black female cast member before that. Not a great look from a simple position of demographics/diversity, but also more practically, awkward if they need to do an impression of a black woman for topical sketches. Unfortunately, I think they’ll probably just rely on an alumni coming in.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

garjones wrote:

The idea of a TV ‘series’ in the UK is next to dead, it is ‘season’ now.

Which is good, because series meaning both a year’s run and the show entirely was pretty confusing.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

Oo, I hadn’t heard of that, but I’ve been wanting to read something from Henrichon since seeing his Dr Strange a while back. Thanks Dave.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Vikram

Yeah, I’m in the beta too. Can’t buy anything (yet) though as they’re only taking card payments and in USD, so I’m not taking the hit on foreign currency transaction fees.

The resale element is interesting. I think it’s mostly there for their “remarqueable” concept, which is where you can get a digital sketch of some sort tied to the comic (I don’t know if it’s layered onto the cover or replaces the cover or what) and so then sell that on. But not all books are remarkable. When I had a look, the only books on the resale bit were all listed at ridiculous prices ($500 for one) which no-one’s going to pay when they, helpfully, have the regular buy button right there on the same page for $4.99. I guess it would make more sense if anyone were selling things on under RRP, which is what I planned to do with a test purchase.

The way they do variant covers (different items but all available from the one product page) makes me wonder if they’re going to try and do some of those as limited editions, to create a resale market around them. IIRC Comixology used to just put all the other variants at the back of the comic, so I’m not sure how well that’ll go down.

I do wonder if they’ve just missed the boat on public opinion about digital ownership for the resale market to work though, as given various comics (mainly DC) say you can’t even download them, you’re really just buying a transferable license to read on-site. But we’re seeing pushback on that kind of thing with lawsuits against Amazon’s “sale” of impermanent digital video that can have access removed at any time..

 

I finished up Frankie Boyle’s novel Mean Time (Meantime? whichever) today and boy that was a bit of a struggle. I like Boyle’s comedy for the most part and I really enjoyed his show New World Order, which was bleak and cynical and kinda nihilistic. But taking that tone, divorcing it from weekly political/social satire and dragging it out into a detective novel is just wearisome. There are some really good lines here and there, even a few good passages, but so much of it is just blandly differentiated characters trading chunks of Boyle’s junkie philosophy to each other.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Bruce

paul f wrote:

The show’s described as a “profoundly serious” crime thriller, which is the first clue that he’s up to something wickedly funny.

I’d have though the first clue was that it’s set in “Bleakford”, but maybe that went over Netflix’s heads.

I’d forgotten about A Touch Of Cloth. I don’t think I ever did see the second (third?) series of that (the one with Karen Gillan).

Criminal that Jane Wickline survived the cast changes. That’s nepotism for ya.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

I feel like I could live with the potential injuries from pissing without needing a guard.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

Arjan Dirkse wrote:

Honestly I don’t even think I would want to win 2 billion. It would completely throw my life into chaos.

Well, if you ever do, you’re welcome to give it to me. I’ll take on that responsibility.

5 users thanked author for this post.

Uncle Retrospective, Al-x, Dave, Sean Robinson, Todd

Al-x wrote:

there are no “lucky” places

Except if you buy them from me. Luck guaranteed.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

So weird that one of the PDD guys is now a featured player, given that’s kinda what they were as PDD anyway and they’ve already got films off the back of it.

Hiring five new cast members only makes sense if more people are being let go, imo.

Oh, Longfellow did stand-up over the weekend where he said he didn’t do a screen test for Weekend Update, which would suggest none of those rumours are true. So I guess Che and Jost are still staying?

New Green leader Polanski vows to ‘replace’ Starmer’s Labour

Zack Polanski has been elected leader of the Green Party of England and Wales by a landslide, signalling a clear shift to the left for the party.

The London Assembly member beat Green MPs Adrian Ramsay and Ellie Chowns, who were standing on a joint ticket, by 20,411 votes to 3,705.

In his victory speech, Polanski promised to build a “green left” to take on Labour, telling Sir Keir Starmer’s party: “We are here to replace you.”

His election potentially opens the door to cooperation with the new left-wing party being set up by former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn and ex-Labour MP Zarah Sultana.

Polanski, a former actor who was the party’s deputy leader, campaigned on an “eco-populism” platform and has promised to make the party “bolder” and more radical in its approach.

In his victory speech, he said: “If you’re feeling hopeless, if you’re feeling in despair, if you’re feeling politically homeless, there is a political home for you.

“And I promise you, nothing will make you feel more inspired, more ready to get out there and more like we can turn our country around than joining the Green Party.”

and yet:

Question to Zach Polanski at the leadership announcement: “Q: How can you take on Nigel Farage when your policy on immigration is so different?” Everything wrong with British politics and media summed up so succinctly in a single absolutely unhinged question.

https://bsky.app/profile/tristangrayford.scot/post/3lxtytwgq6c2n

 

2 users thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle, Uncle Retrospective

On a similar note, I happened to see a bit of BBC Breakfast this morning talking about adding a chicken pox vaccine to MMR and the first immediate benefit they talked about was mitigating the “lost productivity caused by chicken pox”. Not that preventing infection is good in and of itself, but that by kids not getting sick with it, fewer parents will have to take time off work to look after them.

3 users thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle, Uncle Retrospective, Todd

I just got my copy of The Nam Omnibus in. I very much like that it doesn’t have a “volume 1” on the spine (because this has all the good issues, so I would not be buying a volume 2). I’ve not actually taken the shrink wrap off yet but I just noticed it says “printed in Turkey” on the back. That’s new, right? I guess a way to dodge the Trump tariffs.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Uncle Retrospective, Todd, Ben

Looks like SNL is clearing house before season 51. Released so far are

• Devon Walker (3 seasons) – which is fair enough because he’s always been terrible. Not only is he always visibly reading the cue cards, he always seems surprised by what’s on the cue cards. Amazed he got three seasons, frankly.
• Emil Wakim (1 season) – a shame because he was pretty good last season and brought something different to the cast. Plus, I feel like he’d have a pretty good Mamdani impression in him.
• Heidi Gardner (8 seasons) – my initial reaction was “oh no but she’s so good”. Then I saw how long she’s been on the show and, even allowing for the fact that it takes a few seasons to get much of foothold as a featured cast member now, that’s plenty really.
• Michael Longfellow (3 seasons) – this really sucks though. Longfellow is great and it really felt like he was hitting his stride last season. I really wanted him to take over Weekend Update, but I guess not.

I suspect there’ll be at least five more “releases” before the new season. It’s practically an open secret at this point that at least one of Colin Jost and Michael Che are leaving (they’ve been screen-testing new Weekend Update anchors, apparently). Seems foolish to think Kenan will ever leave, but he really should. I’d get rid of Jane Wickline in a heartbeat, but I have a sneaking suspicion she’ll survive. Ashley Padilla seems a lock to not only stay but get promoted to full cast member, but who knows? If Longfellow’s not safe, who is?

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

This is an interesting piece in the New Yorker by Ruby Tandoh about Bake Off – generally and being on it.

Ben wrote:

Booksellers list it as 9 Sept, comic shops get it now.

Best price online so far is SpeedyHen at £18.08.

I didn’t even know they were making it, let alone when it was due out. Although I dimly recall something announcing this alongside the TV commission. is that still happening?

Oh, I didn’t realise there was new Criminal out.

Remember Bugs? It’s back, in p— what do you means you don’t remember Bugs?! It was a key part of the BBC’s 90s “we don’t need Dr Who, we can make plenty of good shows for the same audience” ethos! It had that guy from Neighbours!

Anyway, they’re crowdfunding a sequel special, which I don’t think is going to happen, but who knows. Would probably help if Bugs had been shown on TV at any point in the past 25+ years, I suspect.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/teamphoenix/phoenix-from-the-cast-of-bugs-a-new-beginning

Christian wrote:

Another one that should probably have been handled differently in a Superman movie.

Nah, it’s a dictator. Death’s the best way to deal with them. And what, we’re afraid of offending dictators now?

2 users thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle, Todd

Ben wrote:

Your phone might auto do it because, from your description, I think that’s what I encountered, with the same fix.

I was using my desktop and laptop!

update on the SpeedyHen weirdness: I ended up ringing them this morning, because I didn’t get any explanation about the technical issues and my open pre-order is out on Tuesday and there’s a bank holiday weekend between today and then. Turns out the issue is something to do with case sensitivity. It wasn’t letting me log in without capitalising the first letter of my email address. Which is bizarre because email addresses aren’t case sensitive. I guess that’s maybe something to do with why it then let me open another account with the same email address (because I wasn’t capitalising it, so it thought it was entirely different) and possibly why password resets weren’t going through, because it would presumably reference the given email address with its own list to send the email and it’s thinking C and c aren’t the same letter.

All of which is a very weird error to spontaneously develop. I’m fairly sure I haven’t started changing how I type in my email address (I never capitalise it) so…

I’ve been dipping into FreeVee a bit this week (which, incidentally, is closing down at the end of the month and just being folded into Prime Video). They’re showing the original He-Man series on a continual stream. It’s… er, not very good. But also there’s one showing In The Heat Of The Night. Not the movie, but a TV series that was based on it, starring the guy who played Archie Bunker as the racist police chief. Baffling. I watched a bit, figured it was made in the 70s, some time after the film was made. Nope. Started in 1988. The episode I watched was (somehow) made in 1991. Looked twenty years older. Just looked it up and this thing ran seven years. Seven! For a TV adaptation of a film that’s just about a racist white cop grudgingly accepting that a black guy can also be a cop.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson

It’s a really misleading cover though. I can understand why they thought to use it, but it doesn’t represent the series at all.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Sean Robinson, Dan

Dave wrote:

The biggest loss there for me isn’t so much the joy of channel surfing or the comfort of Saturday morning cartoons, but the possibility of discovering something that you never would have ordinarily chosen for yourself. Loads of my favourite TV shows or movies were things that I initially stumbled across or checked out on a whim, rather than actively wanting to watch already.

Yes, absolutely this. There’s various shows I enjoyed as a kid that I’m not sure I would have actively chosen to watch if given its premise.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Bruce, Todd, Sean Robinson

Dave wrote:

the idea of TV providing specific scheduling at certain times so that kids can watch is a bit of a nonsense. I used to love settling down after school as a kid to flick between the Broom Cupboard and CITV between 4pm and 5:30pm, but now that you can watch what you want when you want, why do you need that time carved out on linear broadcast channels?

I mean on demand programming is great, but there is something to be said for just taking TV as it comes, channel surfing etc. The same way that radio still exists and does well in a world of personal music players, let alone streaming.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Dave

This is possibly going to get a bit old man yells at cloud, but damn it, these are bad clouds.

So it’s the UK school summer holidays at the moment (though the weather has definitely taken a bit of turn, so it’s starting to feel a bit “back to school” season now). As an adult with no kids that’s largely irrelevant to me, but I’m a sucker for nostalgia and it’s hard not to feel a pang of wanting to recapture those past summer holiday joys. As me hanging out in a playground for a day would be frowned upon now, I’ve looked to other areas. And, sad as it might sound, one of my fondest summer holiday memories is getting to just sit around and watch TV all morning. Even in the era of all-day dedicated kids channels, summer holiday programming felt a bit special. CBBC on 2 would run longer into the morning, the Big Breakfast would decamp to a desk in the garden for the Bigger Breakfast. Hell, in 1995 even Sky Movies Gold got in on it and did Schools Out For Summer, showing Transformers, MASK, that weird old Dick Tracy cartoon and finally the Lucy Show (which I never watched, but fondly remember as a sign that it was time to go do something else).

It’s a bit depressing then to see the state of summer holiday programming on TV now. Ok, there are the dedicated kids channels still and they’re probably serving their audiences’ needs (again, childless adult, I don’t know). But ITV has hidden CITV away on ITVX, CBBC is only allowed on its own channel now, not BBC 1 and 2 (with Animal Park being the only summery feeling addition to the schedule – and it’s impressive that’s still going 20 odd years after it started) and even T4 doesn’t exist any more, which is just weird. Channel 4 is probably the most depressing, as it’s only concession to the summer is just playing a few more episodes of all the same sitcoms it’s been endlessly repeating in the mornings for the past twenty years after it gave up on proper morning shows. Another Frasier repeat?! Oh Mr Channel 4, you do spoil us! Props to Channel 5 for Milkshake, which isn’t extended in the summer (still a hard cut to Jeremy Vine at 9am, which must really get the kids switching over), but it’s the only part of Channel 5 that has remained since it launched and hasn’t been hidden away in its own digital TV ghetto. The CBBC thing really annoys me actually – can’t possibly ever simulcast any of that on 1 or 2 cos it has its own channel but the News channel is always treated as a schedule filling fallback.

I know people will say “ah but the kids all watch YouTube now instead” but it’s not entirely that YouTube won the kids over, it’s that TV capitulated on them. And not just in terms of visibility, but presentation. In-vision continuity/presentation is a rarity now but think about what draws kids to those successful YouTube channels like Mr Beast – it’s the familiarity of personalities. Pretty much every successful YT channel is built around its presenters, but TV channels don’t seem to get that. Stuff like TISWAS and Live & Kicking aren’t fondly remembered just because of the cartoons they showed.

Related to all this, one of the shows of summer holidays past I’ve found myself thinking of lately is something called Bug Juice, which I have fond yet dim memories of being on the Bigger Breakfast one year. It was made in 1997/8 and is what we called then a fly-on-the-wall documentary about a US summer camp. I managed to get hold of most of the first series and I’m about halfway in it. It’s really fascinating in several aspects.

First is that it’s an absolute treasure trove for 90s fashion. Which makes sense, I suppose. What’s is a bit surprising though is that I look at the styles and fashion trends and realise that I don’t think I saw any of those in the UK until at least one, maybe two years later. There really was more of a trans-Atlantic delay back then.

Second is that it’s so incredibly and delightfully tame. It’s essentially a predecessor to modern reality shows and even has direct to camera interviews with the kids and counsellors interspersed into the material. With the counsellors especially this is to shape a narrative for the episode, but it’s stark how lacking that is in artifice and fake drama. One episode has the boys cabin, who are mostly 15 year olds, getting annoyed with the one 12 year old that is, for some reason in there with them (even though there are other cabins for kids his age – I don’t know what’s up with that). They just think he’s trying to hard to fit in with them and they want him to calm down a bit. So you get some footage of him being a try-hard, a few to camera bits from him and the other kids talking about the issue, then the discussion the cabin has (led by the counsellor) about it, and a bit of how the kids feel after it and then… yeah, it’s resolved. They show the 12 year old getting into photography, they have to-camera bits where he and the others say they feel better for having talked about it and it all ends pretty positively and relatively weightlessly. If anything, I think they’ve maybe edited some things (like when two of the girls have a spat for a couple of days) to be less dramatic. There’s no way that would happen in a modern show. It would be milked for so much drama, especially with dramatically edited act break cliffhangers, replays of those high drama moments etc (it’s stark how even non-reality shows pad themselves out now by replaying and restating information in each part, compared to Bug Juice, which just gets on with it). Really shows how much TV has changed.

Another wild thing about it is just the summer camp itself. The range of activities they offer is – to this working class Brit – insane. There’s a lake for various kinds of watersports, including a speedboat for water-skiing; various sports fields; arts and crafts, including pottery, photography, candle-making etc; a theatre in which they put on a full play; an outside performance space, in which they put on various other shows; horses; a martial arts centre; archery; general outward bounds camping type stuff; a creative writing course. For one, it sounds exhausting. But I went on a school camp in the Lake District when I was about that age, for a week, and it was literally some semi-permanent tents and a leaky dining hall from which we did archery, kayaking and various things that just involved wandering around a wood. Mind you, I didn’t pay the $20k or so this camp (allegedly) cost, so…

The final thing of note is that it’s hard to watch this and not think about the fact that all these kids are about 40 now. Which is weird. Also that the counsellors are mostly only in their early 20s, so only about five years or so older than the kids, but there’s already this gulf between them. The show mainly focuses on two, one from the boys cabin and one from the girls, and the latter, Luna, is lovely, but her attempts to be the fun cool relatable counsellor with the kids often feel incredibly cringeworthy. And it might well have been that she was just as cringeworthy when she was a teen, but it really highlights that there’s a point at which you just become ineffably othered from teens simply due to age, even if it is an age difference that would be insignificant at later points in life.

There’s an oral history about the show on Vice or somewhere that I’ve got bookmarked and I’m keen to read that when I’ve finished the series.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

Hmm. To their credit, I got an email response today, but they’re not going to be able to look into the account stuff until in the week.

On a more pertinent note, I started reading Wolverine epic collection: Tooth and Claw today. It’s about 9 issues of Wolverine solo series plus a bit of X-Men and some mini-series (including one with Venom) from around 1996. I don’t have very high expectations for it but it was only £11. One issue in and honestly, mid-late 90s Marvel typography is absolutely my jam. The standard dialogue font (I think Meanwhile from Comic Craft) is just the default comic font in my head. The needlessly spangly speech bubbles for different characters, some with their own fonts, are great. The WordArt on the covers. Man, it just speaks to me.

I mean look at that! Pure comics.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Ben

I mean, that’s funny but it’s clearly GenAI “art”.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Dave

Dave wrote:

I also learned how the new generation sees Bond: apparently he is very “chalant” and is constantly “aura farming” for “rizz”.

Ah yes. Just as I suspected.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Dave

I did notice the new password had stronger requirements than my existing password (special characters, numbers etc), so possibly they brought that in and it’s screwed up every existing account with a password that didn’t meet the requirements?

1 user thanked author for this post.

Ben

[Martin Smith]

(This is only tangentially related to tpbs but it seems the best place for it).

Soooo it looks like my SpeedyHen account was deleted? At some point in the past month and a half, since I pre-ordered the Nam Omnibus when that went live in late June. I went to order something else yesterday and it wouldn’t let me log in. Used the password reset thing and I just didn’t get the email. Figured it was a slow email system, ended up buying the book elsewhere.

Then today I tried to log into an entirely different webstore (of a high street chain) that I could have sworn I had an account for – I certainly had a password saved! – and I couldn’t log in and again couldn’t get a password reset email. I thought something was wrong with Gmail but I managed to get password reset emails in from other places. Decided to make a new account on the second place and it let me. I’d use the Paypal check out in the interim for that, so I think it populated my new account with the info from that order, but it had the rewards card I’ve had for ages set up with it. So no idea what’s going on there.

Figured I’d try the same thing with SpeedyHen – I would at least get an “an account already exists with that email address” error if it’s a password issue and… nope, it let me create a new account. None of my existing info is tied to it. Tried the password reset thing with the “new” account and it worked (so it’s not an error on Gmail’s end). The password reset thing doesn’t actually check validity of email address when you use it, it just says “an email has been sent to the address given” even if you use a dummy one, which isn’t helpful. So I guess my account was just gone? Or someone else has broken into it and hijacked it, but I surely would have got an email if they’d tried to change the account’s email address to their own*. And I’ve not had any orders charged to me, so I’m not sure what they’d be getting out of that.

Weird and disconcerting. Anyone else experienced this?

*EDIT: Nope, just checked this and you can change the account’s registered email address with just the password, no confirmation via email. That doesn’t seem great.

• This reply was modified 1 month, 3 weeks ago by Martin Smith.

I can’t believe you’d make such accusations of a future Kennedy Centre honouree and winner of the Noble Peace Prize as soon as he tariffs Norway into giving him one!

6 users thanked author for this post.

JRCarter, lorcan_nagle, Al-x, Christian, Todd, njerry

Wikipedia could reduce UK users as it loses legal challenge against online safety legislation

Wikipedia’s operator has lost a legal challenge to parts of Britain’s Online Safety Act, which it says will drastically reduce the number of users who can access the site.

…

The foundation said if it was subject to so-called Category 1 duties – which would require Wikipedia’s users and contributors’ identities to be verified – it would need to drastically reduce the number of users who can access the site.

Judge Jeremy Johnson dismissed its case but said the Wikimedia Foundation could bring a further challenge if regulator Ofcom “(impermissibly) concludes that Wikipedia is a Category 1 service”.

He added that his decision “does not give Ofcom and the Secretary of State a green light to implement a regime that would significantly impede Wikipedia’s operations”.

The Wikimedia Foundation said the ruling “does not provide the immediate legal protections for Wikipedia that we hoped for”but welcomed the court’s comments emphasising what it said was “the responsibility of Ofcom and the UK government to ensure Wikipedia is protected”.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, lorcan_nagle

DC Finest Plastic Man: The Origin Of Plastic Man

I only bought this because I saw it on that random Amazon DE sale and at about £10 it seemed worth a punt. I didn’t really know what to expect of it. I’ve read literally no Plastic Man comics before, I just know the character from that cartoon he had back in the day (which was in the churn of early Cartoon Network) and some of his Justice League appearances.

Turns out it’s really good. Jack Cole is incredible. In terms of artistry and sophistication he’s about twenty years ahead of pretty much every other Golden Age artist I’ve read. He’s got a nice, clean style that gets progressively more cartoony as he gradually loosens up and leans into a sillier style than the… well, not exactly hard-boiled but proper crime busting tone the comic initially attempts. But he’s also really solid on panel layouts and readability and lettering, which is far from a given with Golden Age comics (especially lettering – in the Superman Finest I read recently it would bounce between clear, professional looking lettering and utter chicken scratch, seemingly at random).

He’s inventive too. Every story opens with a splash page, something that seemed fresh when Marvel started doing it in the mid-60s. He uses these to experiment with logo designs and graphic techniques. The whole thing reads like a very talented artist being given the space to just do what they want and grow.

The most surprising thing is that that Plastic Man (who really isn’t the comedic character I expected. He’s not exactly a straight man, but he’s hardly cracking jokes himself) is given a sidekick – a middle aged man sidekick – and it works. I was dreading that, thinking it was going to be like Doiby Dickles, the dreadful New Yahk cabbie GA Green Lantern got lumbered with. But Woozy Winks actually improves the comic, by giving Plas someone to talk to. His own “powers” (he’s protected by Mother Nature) are unobtrusive, which is helped along by the fact that Cole clearly keeps forgetting about them, and makes a joke of that, and he’s a good comic relief sidekick. I didn’t think it was possible.

This is really good stuff and I’m keen to get more.

4 users thanked author for this post.

Ben, Sean Robinson, Todd, njerry

Man, Fringe promotion is getting out of control.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Uncle Retrospective, lorcan_nagle

Abigail

Horror movie where a bunch of anonymous crims are hired to kidnap the daughter of a crime boss and hold her for 24 hours waiting for a ransom. I don’t want to say more about the plot than that and I wish Sky had felt the same way, because the description on there kinda gave away too much. But then I’m not sure I would have bothered giving it a go if not for knowing the kid is a vampire.

Anyway, it’s got a decent script and a decent cast (the actress playing Abigail is especially good – she played Matilda in the film of the musical of that) though some plot holes: they’re trapped in the house but there’s a couple of places where they could have broken open windows and presumably escaped. Worth a go.

I finished Yakuza 0 tonight. Across the best part of two months, I clocked up 74ish hours and somehow only got a completion rate of less than 50%.

I say “somehow”, I know why – I stepped away from some of the mini-games (which in the case of Real Estate Royale and Cabaret Club Czar is a misleading term) to just focus on finishing the main story. Mostly. I still ended up going back to RER especially just to grind for cash to get ability upgrades. But it was quite strange being incredibly single minded on the just doing the story around chapters 11-14 and seeing how quickly they went by, given that the early chapters seemed to last weeks each. I remember getting to chapter 5 and thinking “well, I’m halfway into the game now, surely”. Friends, I was not even a third into the game.

Anyway, I really enjoyed it. I must say to Ben that you were right, I probably would have been better off playing this one before Kiwame 1. But about two hours into this I realised that it had been longer than I thought since I played that (three years, possibly? Whenever it was that Prince Phillip died. EDIT: four years! cripes) and I could remember next to sod all of what happened in that. I’m going to try and find a story summary of it soon. That said, even from what little I remember of that, I spent the entirety of this game expecting two things to happen: 1) that Majima and Kiryu meet and possibly even fight a bit and 2) that Kiryu ends the game going to prison, which sets up the start of 1, which picks up with his release.. Neither of those happen. Well Kiryu and Majima meet, but it’s literally in a post-credit cut-scene. So I feel a bit wrong-footed by that, but again that’s partially due to me barely remembering much about the first game.

But yeah, it’s crazy how much there is to do in this. As I said, CCC and RER are big enough that they’d have felt like plenty on their own (and CCC frankly could work as a small indie game on its own). But on top of that there’s darts, bowling, batting cages, a fight club you participate in, a fight club for women that you bet on, telephone dating, mahjong, shogi, a full Western casino, fishing, a range of Eastern casino games, karaoke, a nightclub dancing rhythm action game, slot car racing and probably more that I’m forgetting. Plus loads of side-stories. Frankly, it’s too much, actually. Oh and four old Sega arcade games emulated in it (speaking of, I have played enough Space Harrier and Outrun to last a lifetime now).

Another problem with it I have is that it is quite skeevy. All but about two female characters in the game are played by porn actresses and the game rewards you for interacting with these characters (whether that be them being club hostesses you’ve trained, women you’ve met in the awful telephone dating thing, women whose friendship you’ve gained through repeated interactions or just randos in one off sub-stories) with short (very) softcore gravure vids. Which is just dodgy as hell, frankly.

In all, it’s a lot and I can see why it Kiwame feels more recent in my memory than it actually is, because of how big these games are (even if I’ve forgotten 70% of the plot). And the crazy thing is the rate at which they make them. When I played Kiwame in 2021, it was with the aim of it being the start of going through the whole series. In the four years it’s taken me to play a second, they’ve released five more games. I’ve made progress of negative 4. Partly that’s on me, obviously, but also, calm down RGG.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Bruce, Ben

I finished Batman Beyond and it’s ok. It squanders a lot of its potential, I think. On the positive side, I liked Terry a lot, having Bruce sort of end up being Alfred was interesting. I even like Terry’s friend Max being in on his secret and that dynamic (though I can understand why others don’t). And the show creates a decent, original rogue’s gallery, while being somewhat restrained in bringing back old enemies (limiting itself to Mr Freeze, Ras and a legacy Royal Flush Gang, all of which work well).

Where it falls down is that it gets less cohesive and stringently made, I guess, as it goes on. Mid season 2, it switches to the digital ink and paint I was expecting from the off, which looks good but unfortunately comes with a drop in animation quality, with the frame-rate nosediving off a cliff. Season 3 pulls it back, mostly, on that front. But even the Return of the Joker movie, which is animated by TMS, is inconsistent. One second it’ll be silky smooth and then suddenly choppy as hell.

That I can live with. The bigger issues are in other aspects. It’s weird that it spends season one slowly building up Blight (a name which just appears at some point, is never given to him), the man ultimately responsible for Terry’s dad’s death, as the big bad but then he only really has one confrontation with Batman as a proper out and out supervillain at the end of the season. And then that’s it. It’s clearly left open enough for a return down the line, but they don’t bother. In the course of that, they set up Blight’s son, Paxton, as the new head of Wayne-Powers and again as an ambitious conniving antagonist but we don’t see him again until a story that gets rid of him.

The voice cast is generally solid but in season 3 so much of it falls away and is replaced. Stockard Channing is gone as Barbara (presumably busy on the West Wing) and it seems every time someone comes back they’ve been recast (including the aforementioned Paxton Powers). Even a new villain created for season 3, Big Time, doesn’t have the same voice actor across his two appearances. There are some weak episodes in s3 as well, especially the finale, Unmasked, which really teases something significant with its title, but is a throw-away thing about a kid seeing Terry unmasked, all told in flashback (a format I kinda hate). It feels like a show that is just becoming a low priority for everyone involved, to the point that I’m surprised it got the Return of the Joker movie.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, lorcan_nagle

3 users thanked author for this post.

Uncle Retrospective, Todd, lorcan_nagle

I just got hit by the age verification barrier on Reddit, so I thought I’d experiment with it. I’d heard that you can spoof some of them with just photo mode in video games (which I tried last night on Bluesky’s using Ghost of Tsushima, but it didn’t work). Thought I’d really push the boat out and just use a GI Joe Classified figure, because well the head sculpts on them are really good, enough that the camera on my phone will recognise them as faces. And yeah, it worked. As far as Reddit knows, I look like this:

7 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Ben, njerry, lorcan_nagle, Uncle Retrospective, Todd, Sean Robinson

Sean Robinson wrote:

Byrne has written and penciled every page and inked multiple chapters

I’d more interested (and to be clear, I’m not that interested) if he’d been inked by someone else for all of it. Terry Austen ideally (don’t know if he’s still working). Byrne’s art really got worse in the 80s when he started inking himself.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson

Yeah, those have trickled out over a few days, although annoyingly inconsistent on including the contents.

Interesting to see there’s the first two (chronological) Wonder Womna DC Finests out within a couple of months of each other. The Western trade might be the one that convinces me to dip into the “genre” Finests.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson

Stan Sakai’s announced Usagi Yojimbo 1984 at SDCC. It’s the first Usagi story not written or drawn by him, instead by Zack Rosenberg and Jared Cullum, and is set in Osaka in 1984 (presumably still an Usagi style 1984, not real world 1984). Could be interesting!

1 user thanked author for this post.

Ben

Yes ha ha ha yes….

1 user thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle

paul f wrote:

I laughed out loud seeing which people were considered important enough to get their own billing in the end credits.

I must admit, it was quite funny that Mark Gatiss got picture billing. I was talking to my dad the other day, mentioned I was seeing this and he asked who was in it. So I tried to think of people he’d have heard of (Pedro Pascal, because he’s watched Mando, Vanessa Kirby surprisingly) and threw in Mark Gatiss but I said “well, he’s just a TV show host, his bit’s in the trailer but I don’t imagine he’s in the film much.” But yeah, given the very thin supporting cast (which I think was fine, given the film focuses on the family) he’s high up there.

One other thing I liked was that the newsreaders and whatnot in the film all felt very 50s/60s. I don’t know if they were deliberately aping Walter Cronkite, but they definitely got that vibe which is distinct from newsreaders today and it was a crucial part in setting the tone of the period.

Todd wrote:

But in the last episode, a decision was made that undercut the main character completely.

I actually quite liked that the show let Riri be kinda awful and stupid.  She’s conceited, hypocritical, self-centred and arrogant and ends up making an obviously bad decision rooted in that. And that’s an interesting idea for a supposed hero. Now, do I think this is going to be successfully followed up on anywhere, probably not. But, I like that it didn’t feel like the show was desperate to convince me Riri is good.

And I did quite like that last armour she built.

Oo, am I in first?

Saw it this morning (thank you school holidays for 10am showings) and I really liked it. Stylish as heck. Doesn’t punch first and ask questions later, which is nice. Good cast, especially Kirby. Surprisingly restrained in building Earth 828 – sketches in a history for the FF without going “and here’s this world’s Nick Fury!” or whatever.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Dave, Todd

3 users thanked author for this post.

Uncle Retrospective, Todd, lorcan_nagle

Dave wrote:

Ha. The London Formula E races this weekend are also doing a partnership with the Fantastic Four movie, to the point that they’ve been snappily named “2025 Marvel Fantastic Four London E-Prix”.

And also:

As part of the collaboration, Formula E’s signature ATTACK MODE – a strategic feature that gives drivers an extra power boost during a race, requiring them to drive off the racing line and through a designated ATTACK ZONE to activate – will be transformed into Fantastic Four Attack Mode, with other themed elements from the film franchise brought to life throughout the race weekend.

I’m hoping that means like an FF logo trophy or something and not Galactus crushing the Excel centre three laps before the end.

Weirdly, this is the third superhero movie in a row to get some kind of sponsorship deal with Formula E. Huntingdon’s finest, Lola, had Superman livery and racesuits in Berlin the other week while Cupra-Kiro had a Thunderbolts* livery when that came out.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

[lorcan_nagle]

lorcan_nagle wrote:

Yeah, there’s very little difference between cane sugar and high fructose corn syrup, coke will taste the same and be just as bad for you.

• This reply was modified 2 months, 3 weeks ago by lorcan_nagle.

They do have a different taste, HFCS unsurprisingly tasting a bit syrupy. There’s definitely a difference between old UK Dr Pepper (before they added sweeteners) and the US imports I’ve had since and between UK Vanilla Coke (which has disappeared) and imported US Vanilla Coke. But then I’m one of those weirdoes that can absolutely taste the difference between sugar and artificial sweeteners as well.

The most interesting thing about this though is it potentially breaking the stranglehold Iowa corn farmers have on US politics. HFCS is only used because corn is grown to surplus through tax incentives and because Iowa is the first primary no presidential candidate ever wants to suggest scrapping it because it’ll tank them there and derail their entire campaign.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Al-x

Vikram wrote:

one bit I hated (and I’m really surprised that more people aren’t losing their shit over that – it was much worse than the neck snap in that movie, to my eyes).

Well don’t leave us guessing. Which bit?

Much better after your suggestions. Yeah, Kryten was way too small on the original.

4 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Uncle Retrospective, lorcan_nagle, Dave

Which goes hand in hand with the new police state internet where the “won’t somebody think of the children” age restrictions will limit teen access to information about trans people, gender dysphoria etc. Plus the new NHS guidance which basically forces kids into conversion therapy.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Ben, Todd, lorcan_nagle

Todd wrote:

Christian wrote:

I still miss The Colbert Report (not that I’d expect him to do that kind of format again.)

The Colbert Report was at the right place at the right time. It was apex-level satire the likes which I doubt we’ll ever see again. I really hope his next project isn’t a reboot of TCR, as I don’t think it will have the same magic the first one did.

It’d just be too dangerous doing the Report format now. Enough people didn’t get it first time around, you don’t want that went actual fascism is happening.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

Oh, from the way people are acting, I thought the show was older than that, like from the 50s. And I thought it was ending in a couple of months, not May next year.

I mean, it almost certainly is politically motivated, whatever they say. I loved Colbert back on the Report, but the format of the Late Show never worked for me, so I’ve only seen bits of it. It’s never felt like he’s held back particularly, but the next 10 months should hopefully be Colbert totally unleashed.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Todd

I’ve read a couple of Dr Strange epic collections this week and there’s a weird rhythm to them. Volume 3 (which I read a few months ago) is mostly rubbish. It’s got the tail end of the original series, by Thomas and Colan, which is ok but Roy Thomas has some stupid ideas about Strange needing a more traditional secret identity and superhero costume etc. Then it’s a load of absolute dreck when the character is revived before the back end of the volume is Steve Englehart and Frank Brunner’s run, which is amazing. It promised great things for the next volume.

Volume 4 picks up with Englehart’s run, but Gene Colan takes over on art and it’s generally good, but there are peaks and troughs. Until that is Englehart leaves mid-story (with Colan). He’s replaced by Marv Wolfman (who, until a couple of months earlier, had been Englehart’s editor) who trashes completely everything Englehart was doing and starts telling a rambling, uninteresting not entirely coherent story, until he too leaves mid-story . He’s replaced briefly by Jim Starlin, who stays long enough only to pivot the story towards the Inbetweener, who he had used in Warlock. The volume ends with Roger Stern and Tom Sutton taking over, who do a couple of awesome issues, managing to tie together the mess of Wolfman and Starlin’s story while throwing some kindness to Englehart by walking back some of Wolfman’s vindictive changes (Wolfman had Strange give up the mantle of Sorcerer Supreme and become “merely” Master of the Mystic Arts, for reasons passing understanding. Stern just sort of brushes that aside by saying “Sorcerer Supreme” is really a reputation than a job title and who is Strange to say whether he is or not?). So an uneven volume but promising great things for the next volume!

Volume 5 is still technically Stern initially, but he’s just providing plots and Ralph Macchio is scripting them. And they’re fine, there’s an ongoing arc about the Dweller In The Depths throwing people at Strange, but you can feel Stern ebbing away and ultimately the Dweller story just arbitrarily ends. Tom Sutton’s still on art initially, but with different inkers who don’t work as well for him. Then he’s gone and Gene Colan’s back again but inked badly (or rather, inappropriately – I just don’t think Dan Green suits Colan’s style, but given Colans pencils, that’s understandable) and his poor pacing really becomes an issue. Chris Claremont takes over writing and it’s all kinda fine, I guess, but not great. Then, for the last few issues, Roger Stern is back, actually writing completely, with Marshall Rogers on art and Terry Austen inking. And it’s amazing again! It really promises great th–

You’ve fooled me twice, Dr Strange, but not again. I’m keeping my expectations for volume 6 (when it comes out) firmly moderated.

1 user thanked author for this post.

lorcan_nagle

I’m in favour of lowering the voting age, but it is a bit ironic it’s happening at the same time as swathes of the internet are getting age restricted for over-18s. The inconsistency of adulthood across various aspects of the UK is maddening. At 16 you can now vote, have sex (and thus potentially children) and join the army, but you can’t watch violent movies, look at porn or drink alcohol.

3 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, lorcan_nagle, Dave

3 users thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson, Todd, lorcan_nagle

[Martin Smith]

Sean Robinson wrote:

So I guess the Gerard Jones (scumbag!) issue #84 will never see the light of day.

I feel like its omission will lead more people to ask why and find out that a guy who wrote for Marvel turned out to be a paedophile than if they’d just left it in there and not mentioned it. The Streisand Effect, really.

And if it’s on a broad principle of not reprinting the git’s work, well, they included issues of his Wonder Man series in the Operation Galactic Storm epic collection that came out after he was arrested and that’s been reprinted since.

I suppose, as ever with collaborative work, there’s no good answer to this kind of situation.

• This reply was modified 2 months, 4 weeks ago by Martin Smith.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson

Sweet. Just managed to snag Avengers epic: A Traitor Stalks Among (Within?) Us for a mostly reasonable price. That’ll give me a block of 6 unread Avengers epics to binge through and an unbroken run of 11 volumes, I think.

I’d call this bizarre, but Trump has really raised the bar on that word.

Trump says Club World Cup trophy will remain in Oval Office after tournament’s end

US president Donald Trump has claimed that the Club World Cup trophy that has featured prominently in the Oval Office will stay there, and that Fifa made a copy of the trophy that was awarded to Chelsea after their win in the tournament’s final on Sunday.

Trump attended the final along with numerous members of his cabinet and Fifa president Gianni Infantino. The pair of presidents jointly presented the trophy to Chelsea captain Reece James, with Trump staying front-and-center despite the apparent confusion of Chelsea players and the pleading of Infantino.

The incident is just the latest in a long series of intersections between the US president and the world of Fifa, which began in earnest this year soon after Trump started his second term in office. Infantino unveiled the Club World Cup trophy for the first time in an event at the Oval Office in March, and the trophy has stayed there for all subsequent events in the historic space since.

“I said, When are you going to pick up the trophy? [They said] ‘We’re never going to pick it up. You can have it forever in the Oval Office. We’re making a new one,’” Trump said in an interview with official Club World Cup broadcaster Dazn on Sunday. “And they actually made a new one. So that was quite exciting, but it is in the Oval [Office] right now.”

The exact differences between the trophies are unknown, if there are any. Fifa has been approached for clarification.

Incredible that FIFA keep finding new ways to be awful. Not only has Trump apparently been given the prestigious ::cough:: Club World Cup trophy but he nicked a winner’s medal at the final the other day too. There’s video footage of him pocketing it and, I think Infantino, seeing him do this and just sort of giving a resigned nod. And that’s even before you factor in him not getting off the stage for the trophy celebration. I’m so disappointed none of the Chelsea players “accidentally” clouted him during that.

I can definitely see this kind of thing happening again. Not just the World Cup and Olympics (which has the distinct prospect of being Berlin 36 all over again) but there’s about 11 Grand Prix in the US before the end of Trump’s current term and he’s already been to one, before he got back in office (Miami last year).

3 users thanked author for this post.

Todd, Ben, lorcan_nagle

I’ve had Batman Beyond on blu-ray for probably over a year now and I finally, on a whim, decided to start on it, last night. I saw barely any of it (as Batman of the Future over here) when it originally came out, because it was on Cartoon Network at tea-time, so I never had access to the TV at that point. So I’ve seen about 15 minutes total plus the Return of the Joker movie.

Three episodes in, it’s fun and I like it. Impressive voice cast, as always from DC TV of this era. I love the peak y2k opening titles as well. I think one thing that undermines it slightly is that it’s still produced physically with hand-painted backgrounds etc but the visual style they’ve created for it is crying out for the smooth, bright sheen of the computer-aided visuals Justice League had a few years later. But that’s a hindsight nitpick.

Dave wrote:

Martin Smith wrote:

I’m ambivalent about how the Kents were portrayed, but I thought the twist on Jor-El and Lara was interesting. I wish it had more relevance towards the end,

I feel like it became more relevant again at the end, with the closing scene showing Superman watching footage of his Earth parents rather than his Kryptonian parents as he did at the start. It showed how he’d made an active choice in who to follow and who to look up to for moral guidance and was turning away from his birth parents and their intentions – part of the idea of him making his own way and choosing his own values in a new world, in a way that ties into the “immigrant story” take that Gunn was weaving in.

Yeah, that was good, I meant more with the general public. Even just something to suggest that everyone dismissed it as a lie put out by Lex along with all the other stuff.

1 user thanked author for this post.

Dave

[Martin Smith]

I generally liked it.

A few too many characters talking in pure exposition early on, far too little Perry White, a weirdly old looking Jimmy Olsen and a weird take on Supergirl all dragged it down a bit.

But I liked Corenswet as Superman, Brosnahan was as fantastic as I expected as Lois, the Justice Gang all worked better than I feared and Krypto was fun. Superman has never been more relatable as when having to deal with his unruly dog.

I’m ambivalent about how the Kents were portrayed, but I thought the twist on Jor-El and Lara was interesting. I wish it had more relevance towards the end, Superman having to publicly talk about and disavow it rather than it getting seemingly disregarded when Lex was exposed though.

edit: oh and did anyone else think Corenswet as unmaked Ultraman looked remarkably like Brendan Fraser?

• This reply was modified 3 months ago by Martin Smith.

2 users thanked author for this post.

Tobias Radesäter, Sean Robinson

Sean Robinson wrote:

Martin Smith wrote:

IS or WAS –

I get a 404 File Not Found

Oh, there was an extra bit on the URL for some reason throwing it off (even though that’s the URL it gave me ). https://is-or-was.bagpuss.org/

1 user thanked author for this post.

Sean Robinson

[Martin Smith]

So in contrast to Paul, my Amazon De experience: One book was sent two or three days ago and is currently in France. The due date magically slipped from 12th July to 17th for that. The other two still said 12th as of last night but weren’t dispatched until 1am this morning. Surprisingly, they arrived about twenty minutes ago. Clearly, they’ve been sent from the UK and a quick look at the Amazon De stock pages show they’ve sold out of all those books they discounted. I suspect they oversold and had to source some from other Amazons, possibly other suppliers, because my copy of Plastic Man has a stock sticker on the back of it that Amazon doesn’t usually use.

EDIT: and the second book is damaged. Went to arrange a return for a replacement, but it wouldn’t let me. Had to talk to live chat to get and they’ve arranged a free replacement, but then I got an email with instructions to post the original back to Germany at my cost otherwise I’d be charged for the replacement. Had to go back to chat to be told I can disregard this. Replacement isn’t coming til August. ::sigh::

• This reply was modified 3 months ago by Martin Smith.

I haven’t watched any of it since the baseball episode. I really must go back and finish it off. I guess.

This is surprisingly fun:

IS or WAS – the celebrity mortality game!
https://is-or-was.bagpuss.org/%5B/quote%5D

Is Disney showing the ITV stuff internationally or just in the UK. If the latter, I assume it’s just to meet the requirements of having a certain percentage of programming be British made, while ITVX have a few series acts as a shop window to tempt in subscribers. A real coup for ITV would have been TV broadcast of Andor and Only Murders. Would be interesting to see what kind of numbers they got on linear free to air TV.

Gosh, you got those quick! Mine haven’t been sent yet. I suppose it’s an EU thing?