The News Thread
- This topic has 999 replies, 33 voices, and was last updated 2 years, 8 months ago by
.
Author
-
This is taking on a very weird feel now.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
How so, Ben?
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Just the coverage of it, the idea of directed mass mourning. It feels rather odd.
There was this video tribute on the Beeb a short while ago. The full works, editing, music etc, pretty blatant stuff.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
The vitriol it’s raising from royalists too is quite a thing. I said in a WhatsApp group that it was a bit weird that when the BBC stations came back on they were limited to only instrumentals. A friend (well, questionable now) absolutely laid into me, saying I’m worthless compared to Prince Philip, my “desire to watch Bargain Hunt” (?) shows I have an empty life, I should have more respect for such a dedicated public servant etc.
So I guess Phil really hated song lyrics.1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
Martin Rowson has mentioned that Prince Philip really didn’t like the Murdoch Press. Wonder if anyone other than the Guardian would have published that info? I suspect not.
Arjan,
It was pretty full-on, the Gibbs rule applies “if it feels you’re being played, you are”.
It also didn’t need the musical manipulation, the imagery alone would have been more effective.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
-
No. This isn’t about being critical.
The video montage felt artificially emotionally manipulative and it didn’t need that. The images, on their own, told the story of Philip’s life and service perfectly well.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
I think for context Arjan what has got people going is not that tributes are being paid it’s the absolute blanket coverage. The 3 main channels suspending all other shows to play tribute shows for the rest of the day – 2 of them with the same content. Even the toddlers channel showing Teletubbies had a banner telling you to switch over for ‘important news’It seems quite a bit of overkill and something that must have been instructed from on high as that level didn’t happen when the Queen Mother passed away.
Not just the BBC but the commercial ITV station. News sites are reporting that their ratings compares to the previous Friday were down 60% because in the end even if you are a fan of the Duke of Edinburgh does anyone want to watch 6 hours straight of coverage?
I’m not a royalist at all but he didn’t cause any great harm in his life and he did fight in WW2 and set up the very useful D0E Scheme that helps young people with life skills. So shows paying tribute are fine but at the exclusion of nearly everything else is a bit weird and unprecedented really and I know what Ben and Martin are saying it about almost feeling like forced mourning. It comes also with the context of the current government appearing via Zoom on TV shows with massive Union Jacks in their living rooms, which is not normal.
4 users thanked author for this post.
-
Yeah, I was linked to a twitter post yesterday where someone compared a bunch of screens over the M1 displaying the news of Philip’s death to North Korea. Naturally the replies were full of people ranting about how they’re not the same at all, but one person said that unlike the Koreans, the British had chosen to love the royal family.
And I was thinking as I read it: “Really? When did you choose? Do you remember making a choice?”
Really it’s just more Manufacturing of Consent, the media sell a story with government input and it drives public opinion in specific ways. The way that Philip’s death is being portrayed is nationalist propaganda, plain and simple.
5 users thanked author for this post.
-
The other Q is which royals? There’s a good amount of respect and recognition for the Queen, but after that? More variable.
Enough for abolishment? I suspect not. There ate very pro and anti groups, but mostly people will go with the status quo.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
So shows paying tribute are fine but at the exclusion of nearly everything else is a bit weird and unprecedented really and I know what Ben and Martin are saying it about almost feeling like forced mourning
It really is and I don’t think it can be entirely put down to antiquated protocols (which surely would be updated regularly). BBC Four was supposed to show a football match last night, but the channel didn’t come on air, instead telling people to tune to BBC 1. Except at the point when the match should have been shown, it changed to a specially made screen directing people to watch it on the iPlayer. How does that make any sense?
The BBC was getting so many complaints yesterday that it had to set up a special page outside of the usual forms to take people’s details for the eventual response (which’ll likely just stick by what they did).
Another weird thing – Jaguar got a double podium in the Formula E race this afternoon, but their team and drivers weren’t allowed to celebrate during the podium ceremony (while the French driver who won did) because Jaguar has a royal warrant, so has to be officially in mourning, it seems. Which is just such over-sensitive nonsense – does anyone really think Prince Phillip would have wanted someone not celebrating success in a race he had no involvement with because he died?
And now we’re getting 8 days of “official mourning” on top.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
The way that Philip’s death is being portrayed is nationalist propaganda, plain and simple.
Yeah and I think the final bit of context is the eroding feeling of Britishness in the 3 non-English constituent countries of the UK. The response of the government to that seems to be to force traditional Britishness down everyone’s throats, which to me may well cause the opposite effect.
A recent edict came from Westminster that every council must fly the Union Flag and any other flags (the Saltire, Red Dragon or even county flags) must be placed in a lower ‘subservient’ position.
Growing up in Wales we never saw the Union flag that much, we certainly never learnt the words to the UK national anthem or ever played or sung it anywhere. Yet there were always pretty low levels of support of ever leaving the union, that’s changing a lot on recent years and I don’t think shoving the flag and the royals down everyone’s throats is going to solve that for unionists.
By the way on the ratings thing, the most watched programme in the UK was Gogglebox on Channel 4 and none of the royal coverage.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
That flag edict sounds both very dumb and exactly the thing Johnson and co would do. I agree it’s very likely to backfire.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
Though I personally believe the monarchy and its various extensions do wield and have always wielded more political power and influence than is readily apparent, Prince Philip was no better or worse than any other old, famous, wealthy Englishman, and, like the Royal House of Windsor itself, he really wasn’t all that English, was he? Since William the Conqueror, the monarchy has been more or less the last surviving and very visible remnant of the Old European aristocratic systems that went extinct after the World Wars. Like that line in The Crown – it’s a “Half-Scottish, half-German Cuckooland”
Unfortunately, in the former British Empire, there is worse news, but don’t point it out too loudly amidst all the mourning.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
That flag edict sounds both very dumb and exactly the thing Johnson and co would do. I agree it’s very likely to backfire.
I’m surprised he didn’t use them as part of some completely impractical infrastructure scheme. Union jack bridge to Asgard, maybe.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
Bridge? Nah, it’ll be a zipline.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
he really wasn’t all that English, was he?
He’s commonly referred to as ‘Phil the Greek’.
In truth though I think this ‘secret power’ is less to do with monarchy or aristocracy and more to do with going to the ‘right’ schools. 7% of the UK population attend private schools. 2 of the 3 last Prime Ministers were photographed in the same Eton club which carried out ‘larks’ like burning money in front of homeless people.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
-
-
-
-
and, like the Royal House of Windsor itself, he really wasn’t all that English, was he
This line about the house of Windsor not being “English” comes out every so often, but it’s honestly meaningless. Some ancestor of the Queen was born in Germany, but most (probably all) of the population of England isn’t English by that measure.
Before the house of Windsor our monarchs were all Dutch, Scottish, French, and Scandinavian.
-
-
Welsh! I knew I was forgetting one
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
and, like the Royal House of Windsor itself, he really wasn’t all that English, was he
This line about the house of Windsor not being “English” comes out every so often, but it’s honestly meaningless. Some ancestor of the Queen was born in Germany, but most (probably all) of the population of England isn’t English by that measure.
Before the house of Windsor our monarchs were all Dutch, Scottish, French, and Scandinavian.
I think all of European royalty is one inbred family.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
That’s what I mean, though. The Crown is representative of an old tradition, but not essentially a British one. It’s not like the many inhabitants of the former British empire who migrated to the British Isles in recent years and have become English, Welsh, Scottish, etc. Instead, the Crown even moreso than the noble houses, who do trace lineage back sometimes even to the Anglo-Saxons, represents the feudal tradition of international monarchs who owned the land and people of Britain but were not one of them. The earliest kings like the Plantagenets who saw England as a source of revenue but whose interests were primarily in their French holdings (or Crusading off in the damn Holy Lands). Richard the Lion Hearted treated England the way Howard Hughes treated his father’s company Hughes Tool. He gave it to his bookkeeper to run and as long as it provided him with millions of dollars to play with in Hollywood, he couldn’t care less about it.
The nobles ruled the people and the monarch ruled the nobles, and it seems like, historically, the nobility of the land even preferred a Monarch that wasn’t really from Britain or had much personal connection to the British people. I mean, I’m more English than the Royal Family and my family left England in the 1600’s.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Maybe it’s all just a big test run for when the Queen dies. I mean, honestly, how are they going to ramp it up from here? What more can you do? I mean, outside of public self-burnings in the street and every news anchor just crying on the air?
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
I think a point that has been a little missed is that the BBC faced quite a lot of criticism for its coverage some years ago when the Queen Mother died for not being reverential enough, so the coverage of Philip’s death feels like a reaction to that and an over-correction.
Another important change since then is the increasing prevalence of alternate (especially online) sources of news and entertainment since the death of the Queen Mother and certainly since Diana’s death. The BBC is acting as though it can still dictate or at least lead the general public feeling on this, as though people don’t have many other options to turn to, and I think the reaction to their coverage and the viewing figures show that it’s actually quite out of step with the level of interest people actually have in this stuff. It’s quite conceivable that their plans for coverage of his death were made some years ago and are not really in step with the media landscape today, where the BBC is far from having the dominant role that it used to have.
Of course, there’s also a counter argument there that all the complaints about the BBC coverage are a bit overstated because there are actually countless other avenues for entertainment available, even if the BBC are insisting on blanket reporting across their channels. Frankly I’ve barely seen any of the coverage other than a few headlines online because I’ve chosen not to watch it, and to instead spend my weekend watching (and doing) other things.
Finally, another element that I think hasn’t been widely discussed is that the BBC have for years been running scared of a Tory government that’s constantly threatening to dismantle them, and I think their excessive coverage is to some extent playing to the general tone that the government wants to adopt, so all the over-the-top displays of Britishness are in line with that.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
Maybe it’s all just a big test run for when the Queen dies. I mean, honestly, how are they going to ramp it up from here? What more can you do? I mean, outside of public self-burnings in the street and every news anchor just crying on the air?
Rows of beefeaters impaling themselves on their fuzzy hats out of sheer grief.
-
Ha, I was thinking of that too. It’s only become more apt in recent years.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Ha, I was thinking of that too. It’s only become more apt in recent years.
I lost it at the nation of flags line for that exact reason.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Nice to see the i take a slightly different approach by depicting Philip as a Droog today.
6 users thanked author for this post.
-
You have to hand it to them, they’ve played an absolute master stroke here. Just a couple weeks ago it was all the news could talk about, just how raicist the Royal family were. But you even mention it now and you are cast down from society. Christ, we’ve even got Andrew coming out and giving a little speech to the cameras. I wouldn’t be surprised if old Queenie smothered the old goat herself, just to clean up these recent PR nightmares.
7 users thanked author for this post.
-
going to the ‘right’ schools. 7% of the UK population attend private schools. 2 of the 3 last Prime Ministers were photographed in the same Eton club
There’s quite a bit of that here, with so many politicians, senior public servants and judges having all come from a very small pool of schools and colleges.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
-
but if you’re a thick as a plank there’s still only so far you can get on connections.
Leadership of a nation with nuclear weapons is pretty fucking far, to be fair.
5 users thanked author for this post.
-
I definitely agree on the coaching. I’ve mentioned before that when Olchfa Comprehensive school in Swansea had a teacher who approached Oxbridge admission like a private school they got 33 students admitted in 2 years (including Russell T Davies).
On the better education bit? A lot of private schools are at the top end but half the top 100 independent schools have lower than 80% for GSCE passes in 2019. My school had 86% (in a time they were harder). A quick look at the Wales list for 2019 (as last year was rather messed up) has the private Llandovery College with 77% attainment and Llanhari Welsh Medium Comprehensive gets 91%.
I agree it’s not all directly on ‘old boys club’ agreement to get advance people (there is that though, see Toby Young’s dad writing to get him in after failing exams) but it’s pretty clear in many cases people are playing for better connections and the level of self-confidence fee paying schools provide over pure educational reasons.
-
Debenhams to briefly reopen 97 stores in closing down fire sale
Collapsed chain pledges up to 70% off unsold fashion and homeware and half-price beauty products
Time to pencil in a story about crazy crowds of bargain-hunters not respecting social distancing for Monday afternoon.
I’m shocked.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Debenhams has been spamming me with 70% off on-line shopping offers for weeks now. I already bought everything I need off them from the comfort of my armchair.
I guess the people in those queues don’t have the internet
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Debenhams has been spamming me with 70% off on-line shopping offers for weeks now. I already bought everything I need off them from the comfort of my armchair.
I guess the people in those queues don’t have the internet
Some people like to see if clothes fit in person before buying them.
-
-
Debenhams has been spamming me with 70% off on-line shopping offers for weeks now. I already bought everything I need off them from the comfort of my armchair.
I guess the people in those queues don’t have the internet
Some people like to see if clothes fit in person before buying them.
Yes, that thought stopped me buying clothes online for a while, then I realised that I always bought the same clothes in the same sizes anyway, so I looked at the labels in e.g. my jeans and bought exactly the same brand in exactly the same size. And multiple pairs, because they were 70% off, so I should be set for years to come.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
-
The reason why public schools are often worse than private ones is that they’re underfunded
And if funding decisions are made by people with little/no experience outside of the “elite space” or connections to people therein it’s no surprise that not much consideration is given to changing that. They often live in another world.
We don’t have the elite universities, like Oxbridge or Princeton/Harvard/ Yale in the US.
Same; here it tends to be a concentration in certain High Schools.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
And if funding decisions are made by people with little/no experience outside of the “elite space” or connections to people therein it’s no surprise that not much consideration is given to changing that. They often live in another world.
Which was the conclusion Finland made, they actually ban all private education because the people making decisions on the sector often circumvented it for their own kids. They regularly top the European and world education charts since then.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
Sean Hannity Blasted for Calling Adam Toledo, Child Killed by Chicago Police, a ’13-Year-Old Man’
Hannity needs to be blasted. Out of a cannon.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
-
Why is this the case though? I think in the Netherlands most teachers make the same money, so schools are somewhat interchangeable.
Which sounds quite similar to the Finnish system, even if it isn’t legally mandated like there.
There are a number of areas where resources come in though. A big one is class sizes. The more kids there are the harder it is to make sure those struggling keep up or those doing really well are challenged. Local schools here ram each class with 50+ kids which is why I have sent my kids to a private international school where they get 15-20.
I’m not a politician but I am using relative prosperity to circumvent the system which they were trying to avoid in Finland. In countries like the UK and US with very established private school systems you have politicians deciding public education budgets who have no personal stake in the system, so you frequently hear of some real shortages of basic equipment like text books and stationery.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Why is this the case though? I think in the Netherlands most teachers make the same money, so schools are somewhat interchangeable. You don’t have to pay for the salary of some elite “rockstar teacher”. Most high schools are pretty much the same in quality, and are free. You have tuition costs in university but these are the same for all state universities.
Like Gar says, part of it is class sizes, but it’s also workload and school and staff infrastructure (and that doesn’t just mean teachers, but also school psychologists, administration staff, IT people and so on). Proper resources means you have some redundancy so you can cover for sick members of the staff without overextending the people you have, but it also includes stuff like capacities for further training, organisation development and so on. If your school has barely enough personnel and financial resources to just keep swimming, to get the everyday stuff done hanging on by your nails, all the other stuff that’s really important will not get done well. “Rockstar teachers” is a nonsense idea, it’s not a working solution to fix organisational problems in teaching, you need an institutionalised culture of feedback, you need evaluation and development structures and resources (time, mostly!) for training and peer exchange and for development on the job. You need to give people the resources and time to do their jobs well, which is what most of them really, really want to do.
To make a very simple point, these are your teaching hours depending on what country you’re in working in secondary education. Compare the Netherlands to Scotland and America.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
Daaamn, and we’re still dumb as fuck… go figure… u_u
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
The model for a long time now has shown pretty conclusively that while it’s tempting to think so the number of teaching hours and also time in class bear no connection to results.
Students in Finland usually start school anywhere from 9:00 – 9:45 AM. Research has shown that early start times are detrimental to students’ well-being, health, and maturation. Finnish schools start the day later and usually end by 2:00 – 2:45 AM. They have longer class periods and much longer breaks in between. The overall system isn’t there to ram and cram information to their students, but to create an environment of holistic learning.
They regularly sit at the top end of the PISA international rankings.
-
-
Oh no I understood that the graph was teaching hours – hence ‘and also’ for the pupil school hours. However both are connected (if the pupil has 2 hours less in class then so does the teacher even if they have afterwork) and both give the message that just cramming more work onto both parties doesn’t result in improved performance.
It actually extends beyond education and can be seen in the UK’s productivity conundrum. Brits work longer hours than most Europeans but are less productive (measured by hours spent to GDP generated) and have been for years. The right wing tabloids love to blame it on a ‘tea break’ culture and laziness but having worked in several countries that isn’t true, Brits rarely take breaks and often eat lunch at the desk with would be anathema in Asia where they lounge around with long lunches out of the office. It’s just simply for me that quantity and quality are clashing forces.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
Derek Chauvin convicted of murder and manslaughter in George Floyd’s death
MINNEAPOLIS — Derek Chauvin has been convicted of second- and third-degree murder, as well as second-degree manslaughter for his involvement in George Floyd’s death. He faces up to 75 years in prison.The jury read the decision Tuesday, the day after deliberations began.
Second-degree murder carries a maximum sentence of 40 years. Third-degree murder carries a maximum sentence of 25 years. Second-degree manslaughter is punishable by up to 10 years.
The third-degree murder charge had initially been dismissed, but it was reinstated after an appeals court ruling in an unrelated case established new grounds for it days before jury selection started.
The panel of seven women and five men began deliberating Monday after three weeks of witness testimony.
Chauvin, who is white, knelt on Floyd’s neck for more than nine minutes as Floyd, who was Black, was handcuffed and lying on the ground.
Prosecutors argued that Chauvin’s actions caused Floyd to die from low oxygen, or asphyxia. The defense claimed that Floyd’s illegal drug use and a pre-existing heart condition were to blame and urged jurors not to rule out other theories, as well, including exposure to carbon monoxide.
During closing arguments, prosecutors sought to focus jurors’ attention on the 9 minutes, 29 seconds they say Chauvin knelt on Floyd’s neck, while Chauvin’s defense attorney told them that “the 9 minutes and 29 seconds ignores the previous 16 minutes and 59 seconds” of the interaction.
Prosecutors called 38 witnesses, including the teenager who recorded the widely seen bystander video that brought global attention to Floyd’s death. She and other bystanders who testified said they are haunted by Floyd’s death and that they wish they had done more to try to save his life. The defense called seven witnesses, two of whom were experts.
Chauvin had agreed to plead guilty to third-degree murder days after Floyd’s death, but William Barr, then the U.S. attorney general, rejected the deal because, officials said, he was worried that it was too early in the investigation and that it would be perceived as too lenient.
Floyd’s death touched off international protests against police brutality and racial injustice. The city of Minneapolis has spent months preparing for the trial and for the potential of unrest over the verdict.
5 users thanked author for this post.
-
I am honestly surprised he was found guilty.
Not because I don’t think he did it, mind.
4 users thanked author for this post.
-
I am honestly surprised he was found guilty.
Not because I don’t think he did it, mind.
When the verdict came back so quickly, I figured it would be a guilty verdict.
Doesn’t mean I didn’t hold my breath…
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
Good. Fuck him.
4 users thanked author for this post.
-
Now for sentencing.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
I am honestly surprised he was found guilty.
I did expect the guilty verdict, I know police frequently get away with this stuff but I listened to the Guardian daily podcast covering the story and this case was so blatant the rest of the police just threw Chauvin to the wolves. Witness after witness came forward in senior policing roles to say there is nowhere in police training or procedures to explain what he was doing. Other scenarios like shootings are often split second decisions where they can claim a mistake, if you slowly kill a man over 9 minutes that defence is also gone.
The defence had next to nothing to work with other than trying to claim Floyd had a heart attack because he took drugs but the coroner’s report stated that wasn’t true so barring some complete loony tunes on the jury it’s really hard to come to any other verdict.
6 users thanked author for this post.
-
Also, someone needs to shut Nancy Pelosi the fuck up.
A bunch of people tried back on January 6th, but it didn’t go as planned.
5 users thanked author for this post.
-
Annnnnd cops in Ohio shot a 15-year old girl. Apparently one of them shouted “blue lives matter” at people who berated them on the scene.
Also, someone needs to shut Nancy Pelosi the fuck up.
Just read elsewhere that the girl shot was who had called the cops for help.
-
-
-
-
-
-
The US rollout seems pretty fast but quite hap-hazard. One of my FB friends in New Jersey posted his 16 year old daughter is booked in for hers, a day before a 58 year old I know in Chicago who has underlying health conditions. Weird.
We have dropped to no appointment needed here in Rochester. Show up and get a jab then come back in a month for 2.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
The US rollout seems pretty fast but quite hap-hazard. One of my FB friends in New Jersey posted his 16 year old daughter is booked in for hers, a day before a 58 year old I know in Chicago who has underlying health conditions. Weird.
We have dropped to no appointment needed here in Rochester. Show up and get a jab then come back in a month for 2.
Same here in the Houston area.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
At the moment they are only doing that in the KL area that has the most cases but there are more stocks booked and on the way so they could extend it up to Penang.
I’ve just read there are 1 million more AZ vaccines coming through from Covax this month and they’ll be expanding this to Penang. I’ll be first down banging that refresh button on the booking website so fingers crossed.
-
This motherfucker:
Derek Chauvin seeks new trial in George Floyd case
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
The trial was based on evidence and on expert testimony provided by Chauvin’s superiors, peers, and all variety of forensic and medical experts. How is that biased? At the next trial, the prosecutors should just show that 9+ minute video on a loop, every day, over and over again.
-
-
After 4 long years it’s so nice to see the US taking a stance for the benefit of all again and not always self-serving. Thank you Biden.
-
We have dropped to no appointment needed here in Rochester. Show up and get a jab then come back in a month for 2.
I don’t know anyone who’s been vaccinated here. Some of that is due to hesitancy, but a lot more is due to availability.
The ‘Rona is now back in Sydney – we had… two new community cases today. In this instance they don’t actually yet know where the fellow (who so far has only infected his wife) got it. He’s not been overseas and has nothing to do with Hotel Quarantine or health care. One of the great things my state’s health department got right from the beginning was the contact tracing aspect and associated communications. News broke of this guy being a positive case late yesterday, they immediately released a list of where he’d been over the days between when he might have been infectious and when he was tested and isolated. Additional testing sites were immediately established and thousands of people submitted for tests through late last night.
His 10 immediate close contacts were tested yesterday and only his wife has come up positive, which is great news. Today rules have been tightened slightly for the weekend (no dancing, hospitality staff have to wear masks, we all have to wear masks on public transport), but sport and theatre performances will still go ahead, and you can still have up to 20 people in your house (down from 100) – I don’t expect this to blow out.
The positive case has been dubbed “BBQ Man” (and celebrated!) as the published list of his movements made it clear he went on a citywide mission to find a good deal on a BBQ, ending with a meat purchase on Sunday afternoon. Sadly his Covid positive state probably meant he wasn’t able to taste it.
4 users thanked author for this post.
-
I don’t know anyone who’s been vaccinated here. Some of that is due to hesitancy, but a lot more is due to availability.
The only person under the age of 65 I know who’s got it is Mark’s wife, and she works for a pharmacy and they arranged for her to get it as more or less a front-line worker.
I may have applied for a job in a hospital a couple of months ago for similar reasons.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
After 4 long years it’s so nice to see the US taking a stance for the benefit of all again and not always self-serving. Thank you Biden.
Yep. Man, that guy is really firing on all cylinders.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
-
-
This is some mean shit:
Train firm’s ‘worker bonus’ email is actually cybersecurity test
West Midlands Trains workers discover email promising one-off payment is ‘phishing simulation test’
A rail union has hit out at a “cynical and shocking stunt” after a train company emailed staff to promise a bonus to workers who had run trains during the pandemic – only to reveal it was in fact a test of their cybersecurity awareness
West Midlands Trains emailed about 2,500 employees with a message saying its managing director, Julian Edwards, wanted to thank them for their hard work over the past year under Covid-19. The email said they would get a one-off payment as a thank you after “huge strain was placed upon a large number of our workforce”.
However, those who clicked through on the link to read Edwards’ thank you were instead emailed back with a message telling them it was a company-designed “phishing simulation test” and there was to be no bonus. It warned: “This was a test designed by our IT team to entice you to click the link and used both the promise of thanks and financial reward.”
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
That’s awful. And presumably it was an official email from their company accounts, so there’s no reason for any of the employees to have genuine suspicion about it not being legit other than doubting that their company would ever have given them a bonus.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
so there’s no reason for any of the employees to have genuine suspicion about it
Given that the e-mail was supposedly from the managing director, who is apparently the dickhead who signed off on this dickhead “test”, a nice e-mail from him should have been suspicious enough.
5 users thanked author for this post.
-
It also fails as a phishing test by not asking for personal info or bank details, all it tests is ‘will staff click to read a message from the chief exec when it is presented as a bonus announcement sent from his email?’ – the answer is an unsurprising ‘yes, they will’.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
I would assume that it was sent from a non-trustworthy address but the content of the email was made to look somewhat official (albeit with a few giveaways – wonky spelling etc.).
Otherwise that really would be a shitty move if it was actually sent from a legitimate internal address.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
It doesn’t sound like they did those extra steps.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
It also fails as a phishing test by not asking for personal info or bank details, all it tests is ‘will staff click to read a message from the chief exec when it is presented as a bonus announcement sent from his email?’ – the answer is an unsurprising ‘yes, they will’.
Another report says that the email sent them to a form which asked for company log-in information. But it does seem that the initial email was sent from a company address.
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
-
Hey Kalman anything else going on in Israel you want to comment on?
4 users thanked author for this post.
-
-
Dude you were obviously doing a whataboutism by posting that, get real.
2 users thanked author for this post.
-
No, I was just posting something that is part of the whole situation there, that I feel is underreported.
1 user thanked author for this post.
-
3 users thanked author for this post.
-
Surely the Defense had the chance to exclude that person during jury selection and chose not to, so they only have themselves to blame.
Apparently, he didn’t check the “I have been to an anti-police-brutality-rally” box on the form.
Where this one juror is concerned, I think they kinda sorta have a point if you look at the details of it, but it’s ridiculous to think that the fact that he’s been to a BLM march would make a difference to the facts of the case. And I think Chauvin’s defenders aren’t doing him a favour by telling him to fight the verdict.
-
No, I was just posting something that is part of the whole situation there, that I feel is underreported.
Yeah, it’s terrible some of the stuff going on in Jerusalem that people just won’t talk about.
#BREAKING Israeli police storm #AlAqsa compound in the early hours of Monday with heavy tear gas and rubber-coated steel bullets firing at worshippers in the complex and inside Mosque spaces#Jerusalem #Israel #Palestine pic.twitter.com/TCLfY8Z0SK
— Middle East Eye (@MiddleEastEye) May 10, 2021
