I thought it was an absolute mess of a movie for the most part. A few fun moments, but mostly pretty incoherent and sloppy.
The one saving grace is Keaton, who is limited in how much he has to do (given that he only shows up halfway through) but makes the most of pretty much all his scenes, with a decent performance that genuinely feels like an older version of the Burton Batman, who has lived an interesting life.
But for the most part, the movie just has so many moments where you think “what were they thinking?”
Miller is maybe the most unlikeable lead I’ve seen in a superhero movie – his weird semi-autistic(?) Big Bang Theory interpretation of Barry feels like completely the wrong choice for a film like this – the story feels incredibly cobbled together (there are setups with no payoff, and payoffs that come with no setup, and plot lines that vanish entirely by the end – like Supergirl), and the tone is constantly whiplashing between a core storyline that’s serious and dramatic, and constant moments of pisstakey cartoonish Looney Tunes stuff.
Plus the CGI, while occasionally good, is very weird and almost Pixar-like stylised in places. It gets very videogamey even for fairly realistic scenes – like the babies being saved at the beginning of the movie, which just looked freakish. It felt less like a deliberate stylistic choice and more like a cost-cutting budget issue.
Plus Affleck feels like he’s starring in Contractual Obligation: The Movie.
The weirdest bit for me though was the whole sequence with the glimpse of the alternate universes. Not only was it completely empty fanservice that didn’t really have much to do with the rest of the movie, but it also felt pretty bad-taste at times, particularly the plasticky CGI recreations of Christopher Reeve and Adam West. And the Nic Cage section was just a baffling inclusion even as an in-joke.
I was hoping for much more out of this movie, particularly after the promising trailers and Gunn’s warm words about it. But I ended up feeling like they should have binned the whole thing, and maybe made a Keaton DKR movie instead.
Certainly the final Clooney gag just felt like it existed to underscore how conspicuously this iteration of the DC movie universe has fallen on its arse. We can only hope that this is a slate-clean that will allow future movies to be better.
1 user thanked author for this post.