Westworld

Author
Topic
#5945

Season 3 is going to arrive in early 2020 and has dropped a new very perplexing trailer

Viewing 83 replies - 1 through 83 (of 83 total)
Author
Replies
  • #5954

    And the website;
    .
    https://inciteinc.com/

  • #6357

    Interesting. So, are the robots going to take over the world by using capitalism? It’d be a cool premise.

  • #6412

    Interesting. So, are the robots going to take over the world by using capitalism? It’d be a cool premise.

    I wonder how that makes @LORCAN_NAGLE feel?

  • #6422

    I wonder how that makes @lorcan_nagle feel?

    It’s about as big a conflict as I can imagine for Lorcan. On the one hand, capitalism; on the other hand, robots.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #15360

    https://www.hbo.com/video/westworld/seasons/season-3/videos/s3-trailer

    bumped for trailer. less than a month, Can’t wait.

  • #15456

    Second hidden trailer that you needed to go to a site from the first trailer with a clean VPN to find:

  • #15459

    Yep, looking forward to this.

  • #15502

    The new Westworld trailer is my favourite thing.

    Ed Harris has found his purpose.

  • #15505

    Ed Harris for President

  • #15604

    Second hidden trailer that you needed to go to a site from the first trailer with a clean VPN to find:

    Neat!

    God, I hope this is going to be as good as it looks.

    I wonder if they’re going to screw with the chronology of the storytelling again. It’s become a bit of a trademark, and while I realise it didn’t work for many in S2, it did for me. But I do hope they tell the story in a straighter fashion this time. I am kind of assuming so, too – the non-linear storytelling was fine for the little puzzle box that was the Park, but in the “real” world, it makes far less sense to tell the story in that way.

  • #15627

    I wonder if they’re going to screw with the chronology of the storytelling again.

    That’s their thing. I’ll be surprised if they don’t do it.

  • #15728

    My favorite part of the trailer is at 2:11 where you see Dolores still has Wyatt’s personality inside her.  “Kill Everyone”.

  • #16887

    I had forgotten a lot of this.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #17020

    Not watching it yet, but I’ll definitely need a recap before watching season 3, cheers!

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #17849

    Okay, so I watched Season 3, Episode 1 last night. I’m going to have to watch it again because the dialogue was very low-volume and I missed half of what people were saying. Many new characters introduced, some of whom actually survived to the end of the episode. I have no idea what the hell is going on, so it’s very much like the first two seasons in that respect.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #17898

    I liked that a lot more than season 2, which just felt like a lot of people running around with no direction or purpose. This was something new and interesting.

    And I had subtitles, so I didn’t have to hear what they were saying. :scratch:

  • #17917

    Yeah this first episode was FAR better than S2… And see? they didn’t need any bullshit time skipping crap… I wonder if they changed writers.

    I didn’t love the midcredit thing though, that was a bad callback to the previous seasons, and I’d rather move forward… also Nazi Wolrd just sounds boring… there’s been enough of that stuff recently on TV, so I hope they won’t dwell too much on it. Really seems like it’s gonna be filler.

  • #18546

    I forgot to delete the scheduling from the DVR so I ended up recording it. I watched it that was so fucking BORING. I really don’t care about Dolores and her plans.

    I made sure to delete the it from my schedule this time.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #18561

    Well, to be fair, I didn’t say it was good… I just said it was better than that S2 godawful mess… =P

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #18617

    Well, to be fair, I didn’t say it was good… I just said it was better than that S2 godawful mess… =P

    Hell, the coronavirus is better than Season 2.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #18703

    Well, I liked Season 2.

    My only reservation with season 3 is so far they haven’t given Aaron Paul a chance to say, “Science, bitch.”

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #18731

    You’re all missing out.

    I’m still laughing at what’s Inside Park Number D.

  • #18732

    they didn’t need any bullshit time skipping crap

     

    Remember in S1 when we also assumed everything was happening in the same time frame? :unsure:

     

     

  • #18744

    This season kind of reminds me of that season of Walking Dead where the characters were separated and each episode focused on one or two of them, until they started to meet up with each other toward the second half of the season. Looks like we’ll finally see Charlotte next week. At this rate, there might be a Coronavirus vaccine before we see Ed Harris.

  • #18765

    they didn’t need any bullshit time skipping crap

     

    Remember in S1 when we also assumed everything was happening in the same time frame? :unsure:

     

     

    Oh fuck… you’re right… =/

    Now that I think about it, yeah there could be some time skipping shenanigans going on here as well… ugh… I really hope not.

  • #18783

    The pace redefines “leisurely”.

    So much talent and money, so little story for so many episodes.

    But maybe that’s just me? Are most people enjoying the set-piece bits? I want to enjoy them but I’m fining them leaden and just there to fill episode time. They’re not plot or character, they’re indulgence.

    I do like the characters still.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #19137

    I’m intrigued by a lot of the individual elements, but not at all engrossed in the story. There’s too much vagueness, obfuscation for the sake of dragging out an uninteresting mystery. I’ve watched two (out of eight?) episodes, and I’m still not at all clear on what the plot is, nor do I really care.

    In season 1 I could probably have said the same, but it didn’t matter because I was too interested in exploring the world and the ideas. This season isn’t introducing anything new that comes remotely near matching the concepts season 1 made us grapple with, and with that stripped away all you’re left with is a non-compelling story.

    I’m still watching but if the channel dropped it next week I wouldn’t be heartbroken (and would probably quickly forget about it).

     

  • #19143

    remotely near matching the concepts season 1 made us grapple with

    Well I mean, they weren’t particularly amazing, tbh. It’s the sort of stuff we’ve already read/watched/played about many times by this point.

    I actually find myself a lot more interested in this season, because at least for now, the stakes seem to be higher… And while, like for S1, there isn’t anything particularly new or amazing in here either, it at least has a lot of potential… though I’m not gonna raise my hopes up just yet, ’cause odds are they probably won’t live up to that potential…

    Anyways, I actually enjoyed this second episode, they did some interesting things with Maeve, and thankfully that world was just a one-off… I’m honestly over the whole westworld concept by now, so I’d rather they focus on the real world and all that… there’s a lot more to be explored there, let’s hope they will. I’m actually more interested by this ‘real’ world they’re depicting.

  • #21109

    The latest episode was very well shot but damn it was fucking cliched and stupid.

    The cyberpunk backstreets straight out of a William Gibson novel, The Eyes Wide Shut (charity) auction, Vincent Cassel being billionaire gangster. I can get crap like this from the places they go it from, or I can watch ‘Altered Carbon’, which was never anything more than a tribute act anyway.

    Season One was a long time ago.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #21130

    I’m actually enjoying this a lot more than seasons 1 and 2… :unsure:

    I kinda wish they had mashed s1 & 2 together.

  • #21148

    Season One of Westworld has never been closer with all the mirroring of prior scenes this week. They’re echoing elements of S2 too. This series is deceptively simple on the surface but reminds me of an episode of Legion and the best episodes of Person of Interest and Mr. Robot. Ridiculously intricate.

    I thought the Game of Thrones easter egg was just a nice nod to the fan fun of it being another park. Now with all the alchemical symbolism going on, even that seems deliberate. Great subtle use of costumes this season too. Ooooh, just occurred: Dolores and her quick-change gold dress = more alchemy.

    The twist on Casablanca’s Paris line was clever. Last week was devastating whilst also riffing off of Dickens which seems to be an ongoing theme.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #21191

    Game of Thrones? Casablanca? DICKENS?!!

    I need to start paying closer attention…

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #21193

    What the dickens have you been watching, Jerry? Yul Brynner?

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #21781

    As of yesterday afternoon, I had decided to give up on this season since, 4 episodes in, nothing was happening and I wasn’t emotionally or intellectually invested in any of the characters. But at 9pm I found myself switching on the newest episode.

    I’m glad I did. Without spoiling anything, this episode has done a lot of explaining via backstory, and clarifying the relationships between characters. I was actually able to follow along this time, so I guess I’m sucked in for a few more episodes at least.

  • #21866

    As of yesterday afternoon, I had decided to give up on this season since, 4 episodes in, nothing was happening and I wasn’t emotionally or intellectually invested in any of the characters. But at 9pm I found myself switching on the newest episode.

    I’m glad I did. Without spoiling anything, this episode has done a lot of explaining via backstory, and clarifying the relationships between characters. I was actually able to follow along this time, so I guess I’m sucked in for a few more episodes at least.

    This season is only 9 episodes long.

  • #21917

    I’m done.

    I’ll skim each episode from now on and hope I start to like it again.

    Some of the ideas are interesting, but only some.

  • #21922

    This season is only 9 episodes long.

    Eight episodes, actually (according to the season 3 Wikipedia page).

  • #22161

    Hm. I am glad I am not watching the single episodes, then, but waiting for the whole season to be finished. I’ve made the experience with the other two seasons that I quite like blasting through it in a few sittings.

  • #22165

    I’m doing exactly the same. I seem to have enjoyed both series a little more than the online average, and I wonder whether watching it all in a short space of time works better for this show.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #22178

    Spoilers for Westworld Season3 finale

    It turn out it was earth all along!

    Also it turns out they were a robot all along!

    Also it turns out they were just a projection of their multiple personality!

    Also it turns out the book said to serve humans IN HELL!

    Also it turns out everyone is dead and it’s the afterlife!

    Also, as it turns out, you have to watch the series IN REVERSE to really understand the narrative, which, ultimately, is a message about friendship conquering everything.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #22181

    OMG GENIUS WHY AREN’T YOU WRITING ALL THE SHOWS??

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #22183

    It turns out I am which is why all the shows are great universally loved!

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #22188

    I’ve been watching Westworld diagonally sideways and upsidedown like a hypercube.

    Can you give me some hints about what’s coming up in TimWorld? I won’t tell the others.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #22193

    I’ve been watching Westworld diagonally sideways and upsidedown like a hypercube.

    That sounds like you’re watching it in a regular cube. Pfft. Try watching it ana and kata, like a real fan.

  • #22198

    Well I’ve enjoyed this season A LOT more than the previous two, to my surprise… I think it’s got to do with a flaw in the premise of the show (for S1&2)… well, I say “flaw”, but I guess it depends on your perspective…

    But for me, the “flaw” was that the park is a “fake” world, and sure, I know the whole show is a fake world because it’s fiction, but the point is that IF you know from the get go that the park is fake and hosts are robots, it’s hard to care about whatever happens in it, because in the end, there’s no real consquences for the most part… that’s specially true for season 2 where the show focused more heavily on the hosts. I guess the best part of the show was always the human side of it, but even that part was always envelopped in a “what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas” kind of deal where it felt that none of it really mattered.

    Obviously the show couldn’t be what it is currently without those 2 previous seasons, but I still feel like they could’ve squished it into one season, tbh, by removing a lot of unnecessary fat from both seasons and the show as a whole would be better for it.

    Anyways, my point is, now that the show is happening in the “real” world, it’s A LOT more interesting to me… but sure, it’s almost like a completely different show, so I guess I can see why people who enjoyed the show within the parks wouldn’t necessarily like this.

  • #24415

    I did a group watch, for Lockdown. The story has picked up a bit and some of the twists were really twisty and unexpected.

    There’s an ongoing problem with the action being unnecessary and a lot of the villain’s actions being cliched. The ideas that work are much better than the material around them. I know HBO has expectations of shows like this, for blood, nudity and violence, but those aspects feel tacked on a lot of the time.

    And speaking of nudity, if Evan Rachel Wood doesn’t want to do a scene naked then why choose to give her Lady Godiva hair to cover her body? Why not have Dolores wear clothes? Her blue dress for example? The scene would’ve been just as effective.

  • #24416

    I’ve really liked what they’ve done with this 3rd season so far with a couple of caveats, but I’ll discuss that when the show is over… This has been a VAST improvement though. The lack of useless time-skips has helped very much, too.

  • #24781

    Now that this season has finished I can start watching it – I waited in the same way for both the first and second seasons and seemed to enjoy it more than most that way.

    Started with the first episode last night and enjoyed it, although the change in setting feels like a big shift for the show, almost a soft reboot. Aaron Paul is very good though and there’s some great world-expanding detail in there – it feels like the scope of the show has expanded massively. Disappointed not to see Maeve as Thandie Newton is my favourite thing about the show, but hopefully she’ll be along before too long.

  • #24802

    Hm.

    Debating whether to get Sky for a month or buy Westworld 3 on amazon.

    Advantage Sky: I can also watch other shit, like the last Rick & Morty season.

    Advantage buying: I own the season afterwards forFOREVER!

  • #24811

    So hardly anyone here was watching this season as it was broadcast? :unsure:

    Ok, then no spoilers.

    See what you think?

  • #24864

    I watched each episode as it aired, every Sunday night at 9pm for the last eight weeks. I kept hoping it would eventually make sense.

    I will note that when I re-watched previous episodes, they made more sense the second or third time around due to the additional information I received from subsequent eps. I suppose if I watch the whole season again, knowing what I know (or think I know) now, my feeling about the series may improve.

  • #24910

    Well this season was MUCH better… I’m now looking forward to season 4, which is kind of an 180 degree from when season 2 ended…

    It’s definetly a good thing they dropped the whole time skipping bullshit and as far as I’m concerned, bringing the plot to the “real world” was a massive win… and even though there was some filler this season, it was much tighter than the first two, which honestly ended up being a lot of not much.

    I’ll say it again, if they had condensed the first two seasons into one by cutting all the useless side filler and by not using those silly time skips, the show would be A LOT stronger.

    Anyways, I don’t wanna go into details/spoilers just yet, ’cause it seems a lot of you still haven’t watched it… so… I dunno, I’ll wait for a bit I guess… =/

  • #24955

    I watched each episode as it aired, every Sunday night at 9pm for the last eight weeks. I kept hoping it would eventually make sense.

    I will note that when I re-watched previous episodes, they made more sense the second or third time around due to the additional information I received from subsequent eps. I suppose if I watch the whole season again, knowing what I know (or think I know) now, my feeling about the series may improve.

    I watched every episode when it was available and in watching the new one right now.

    Generally, I felt there wasn’t much like for it here so I didn’t feel very inclined to comment.

    Some episodes I thought were great, some I kind of blanked through.  The finale is promising so far.

    It does seem to be a show,  due to its intricate plots, that rewards more on the rewatch then it gives the viewer on the initial watch.  That’s probably a questionable approach, but certainly works for it’s fans.

     

  • #24973

    I liked it.

    It’s too intricate and layered to sum up each episode in a few words.

    The subtle ways they portrayed the glitches in predicted time was fun to spot.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #25011

    Now that this season has finished I can start watching it – I waited in the same way for both the first and second seasons and seemed to enjoy it more than most that way.

    Started with the first episode last night and enjoyed it, although the change in setting feels like a big shift for the show, almost a soft reboot. Aaron Paul is very good though and there’s some great world-expanding detail in there – it feels like the scope of the show has expanded massively. Disappointed not to see Maeve as Thandie Newton is my favourite thing about the show, but hopefully she’ll be along before too long.

    I thought Maeve was in a post-credits scene in episode one. You didn’t miss it did you?

    I think the Post-Credits scenes are only in the first and last episodes.

  • #25056

    ‘Westworld’ Creators On Season 3 Finale; The Dangers Of AI; The Futures Of Bernard, Dolores & Man In Black

  • #25062

    I enjoyed their use of the Pink Floyd track;

    It’s great when a company can afford the right track at the right time.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #25121

    I enjoyed the episode with its use of genre score.

  • #25724

    I have now watched all of the S3 episodes. I even watched the end of the S2 finale because I was wrong about something. While Thandie, Aaron, and Vincent did wonderful, my focus was on Tessa and Evan Rachel. The way they started out and grew apart was fascinating. I watched it on Amazon Prime and one of the descriptions for one of the later episode referred to Tessa as Haloris and it fit. Tessa did a great job of creating the new character of Haloris(although they could have come up with a better name than a typo for bad breath, maybe Charnathy(?)). Evan Rachel did an equally good job with Deloris(too spoilery to elaborate)

    The scene in which they used Pink Floyd fit so perfectly.

    What I had gotten wrong in S2 finale is Wyatt was not his own pearl just some code Ford had added to Deloris’ code. I don’t know how far everyone has gotten along but when I found out who was imprinted on those 5 pearls in Hale’s purse from the S2 finale was a highlight for me.

    Thandie did another fantastic job as Maeve. at the end there was a deus a machina which I didn’t understand, but other than that She was great  and her interaction with Hector(no spoilers) was special.

    Aaron did very well but I am biased and he is no Teddy.

    Vincent was a great adversary(he was not a clear cut villain and the series was about choice so good and evil were left up to you to decide) for Deloris and his last line was classic.

    I have never liked William(the ed Harris version) so watching him suffer this season was enjoyable. William is like a cockroach and I hope we don’t see him in Season 4. Of course Ed Harris will be back. He is a great actor and I enjoyed watching him in the group session this season.

    Jeffrey did a very solid job as Bernard and the contrast between the last 2 finales was a very nice touch.

    Jon mentioned fillers and I thought the Genre episode was somewhat filler but like Bernadette said it was a good concept.

    I’d love to discuss details so when you finish, come into the thread and we’ll go for it.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #25802

    DOLORES… say it with me… =P

    but when I found out who was imprinted on those 5 pearls in Hale’s purse from the S2 finale was a highlight for me.

    yeah that was a legit good twist for once… however it wasn’t entirely clear whether it was all Dolores or if the other pearls were actually a mix… a mix sounds like it’s what it was, but they weren’t super clear about it.

    There were a couple of things that were bothering me while I was watching… mainly how Dolores went from a villain to the “good” guy, but fortunately they adressed some of them in the last couple of episodes…

    What I liked about this season is how they applied the simple concept of the park and took it waaay further applying it to the real world, where it turns out the “real” world has pretty much become a park of a sort, however I’m not sure I liked that in the end it was a machine calling the shots, or so it seemed at least, since Vincent pretty much seemed to be a puppet in that last episode.

    But anyways, yeah, this was easily the best season. I’m curious to know if they’ll renew it.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #25806

    https://www.harpersbazaar.com/culture/film-tv/a31981161/westworld-season-4-news-cast-spoilers-date/

    HBO announced on April 22 that it officially ordered a fourth season

    Show creators Lisa Joy and Jonathan Nolan had previously told Variety they hope to make at least one more season to wrap up the Westworld story (and possibly more). “We can’t wait to see where their inspired vision takes us next,” HBO’s programming president Casey Bloys said in a statement.

    • This reply was modified 4 years, 7 months ago by Rocket.
  • #25816

    Ah well, that’s cool… shame it seems ERW ain’t coming back… I really liked her this season. I know she’ll probably be in there as a cameo or something, but I really like her and Aaron’s duo.

  • #25906

    I think she will be there. did you miss the quote where they said “THIS” version of Dolores won’t be back. I bet Haloris still has a Dolores pearl left somewhere but we will see. S4 will likely be the last because Nolan and Joy are now at Amazon creating a new show.

  • #25934

    I didn’t miss it, but to me it looked like ERW is out… them being coy with the “this version” thing kinda reinforces the notion. Although again, I’m sure she’ll have a cameo before the end. But hey, I hope I’m wrong…

  • #26070

    There’s an old Hitchcock quote about why you shouldn’t confuse an audience because a confused audience isn’t emoting, and that’s how I feel about Westworld season 3, which I just finished tonight.

    The characters’ goals and motivations were so opaque a lot of the time – sometimes you weren’t even meant to know for sure who certain characters even were! – that it was really hard to engage with. Which I didn’t find to be the case with seasons 1 and 2.

    So while this third season explored some interesting ideas and had some exciting sequence and decent individual moments, I just didn’t feel like I cared about any of it. I feel like it was a waste of time that could have been better spent.

  • #26185

    I feel the exact opposite… :unsure:

    To me, seasons 1 & 2 were just confuising for the sake of being confusing (the whole time skip thing, mainly)… season 3 wasn’t. Sure, some motivations weren’t clear, but that’s about normal in this type of stories, it’s part of the suspense, and that was NOT the main problem with S1 & 2…

    Unfortunately, the one character I’ve never really cared about is Bernard, and it seems he’s gonna be the focus of next season, which is a shame.

  • #26241

    I thought Bernard was really poorly served this season. They basically just kept him hanging around with busywork until the end.

    To me, seasons 1 & 2 were just confuising for the sake of being confusing (the whole time skip thing, mainly)

    The chronology reveal in season one was great and made for an excellent twist that realy brought everything together. In season two it was more forced and I’m glad they didn’t try to repeat it here.

    Sure, some motivations weren’t clear, but that’s about normal in this type of stories, it’s part of the suspense

    The suspense of finding out what’s actually going in in the show you’re watching!

  • #26290

    The suspense of finding out what’s actually going in in the show you’re watching!

    Nah, they stated it pretty early… Dolores was trying to hack Rehobam or whatever the fuck that thing was called… I mean, that was basically the plot of the season: Dolores trying to stop it, and then some other folks trying to stop her.

    As for season 1, I’m not sure I’d call it an excellent twist, but at least it kinda worked, but for sure, in season 2 it was forced in and completely unnecessary… but I mean, that goes for most of season 2, in general…

  • #26379

    I agree Bernard was poorly served this season.

    This season was about Dolores’ plan and the effects it had on people.

    Maeve was pretty much enslaved and tortured because Vincent felt he need a counter to Dolores. Caleb was a pawn. I don’t think he did anything on his own. The other pearls were treated like pawns by Dolores who did not care whether they lived or died. One of my favorite scenes was when Haloris(Tessa) confronted her during that shootout. im not so sure next season will be able Bernard. Haloris is building an army and her plans for the Man in Black do not look good.

  • #26913

    So, I started watching this.

    Loved the first three episodes, and how they focus on different characters (Dolores, Maeve, “Charlotte”). Caleb is a good addition to the cast, and I liked the device of him talking to the AI psychotherapist. Overall, I like how full-on sci-fi they’ve gone in many ways (which they couldn’t in the park environment, of course).

    Looking forward to the next episodes!

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27673

    Alright! Finished now!

    The characters’ goals and motivations were so opaque a lot of the time – sometimes you weren’t even meant to know for sure who certain characters even were! – that it was really hard to engage with. Which I didn’t find to be the case with seasons 1 and 2.

    I didn’t have that feeling at all. I mean, Caleb just wants to be overcome his trauma and build his life, and he has a deep anger at the people who damaged him. His motivations keep unfolding, of course. Charlotte was fighting for her cause, but also slipping into the human Charlotte’s life, resulting in emotional confusion and her trying to save her husband and kid. Bernard and whatshisname were trying to stop Dolores from ending the world. Dolores still wants to build a place for her kind; ultimately, it is only the way in which she goes about it that stays obscure. Maeve wants to find and be with her kid. Serac wants to end chaos by controlling everything. I found all of that pretty relatable really. Maybe it’s a matter of binge-watching it all at once.

    The world sinking into chaos was the part that didn’t quite work for me; it was just too quick, and it was all just rioting in the streets… I don’t know, the end of the world felt a bit one-note. Thematic though, given what’s going on in the US right now.

    Other than that, I am very happy with the finale, and with the season overall. And it’s interesting that Charlotte is going to be the villain for S4, and that it’ll be hosts vs hosts apparently.

    Another thing I noticed, and that was only reinforced by whatshisname, Veronica’s Mars’ dad, showing up is that this season of Westworld was just as much a capstone to the themes and ideas of Person of Interest – two artifical intelligences warring, one trying to control the future and the other trying to set it free. Even Serac turning out to be the AI’s puppet is an idea directly lifted from Person of Interest. Which is fine, I mean, it’s all Nolan’s creations and it feels a bit like he tied one to the other here discreetly – change a few details and you can almost imagine that the world of Westworld is the future of Person of Interest’s world.

    Which reminds me, I don’t think I every watched the last season of PI. Good time to go back and do that now, I suppose.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27680

    Maybe it’s a matter of binge-watching it all at once

    No, it’s not that as I did the same.

    I think this series just played its cards too close to its chest early on. For example, creating a mystery about who Dolores’ accomplices were didn’t really achieve anything other than provide an artificial “what’s going on?” mystery. Same with Caleb’s mystery backstory really. They just felt like mysteries for their own sake.

  • #27686

    Fair enough where Dolores’ helpers are concerned, but sometimes creating a mystery does have value in this kind of TV show – I don’t think it’s particularly deplorable. I also think it does have another point, as it changes how we see Charlottes journey: we first see her as an individual host, then we find out she’s just a copy and expect her to behave like Dolores’ other duplicates, then she develops individuality and in the end rises up against her maker – mirroring Dolores’ own journey, only she rises up against Dolores herself now.

    Similarly, Caleb’s journey of self-discovery is important because it enables him to make the choices he does in the end. But Caleb’s backstory and its being bureid also ties directly into the plot of the season. Where that is concerned, I’d rather say that it’s the opposite problem, really, that it’s too much constructed around the plot to be entirely convincing. I mean, like how for some reason the Machine decides it has to off one of the guys executing the personal for Veronica’s dad, which doesn’t make a lot of sense in the first place, but then when he’s killed the other guy, they don’t just finish him, as well, while they’re at it but make the effort of reprogramming him instead of just shooting him, which surely must’ve been the best possible outcome of putting out contracts on each other for the two guys?

    But they needed different levels of Caleb’s backstory to get him where they wanted to in the plot, so the problem is more that his backstory achieved too much, plot-wise, rather than just a mystery in itself. But like I said, I liked it well enough mainly because it is another thematic mirror of Dolores – Caleb has to figure out that he isn’t who he thought he was, and that discovery sets him free to act against his former masters.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #27697

    I agree that Charlotte’s arc was compelling, but only once we knew that she was another Dolores, so all that fannying around in the first few episodes making us guess who she might be felt like wasted time (especially in a truncated season). It was like all the “who is Ronin” stuff in Bendis’ Avengers.

    But I don’t agree that Caleb was really changed significantly  a result of his discovery, other than finding another reason to do what he was already doing before in helping Dolores, so that mystery again didn’t really land for me.

    I can’t remember if you watched Devs yet Christian, but I think part of the problem for me may have been that I watched that immediately before season three of Westworld, and it dealt with similar ideas around AI and predestination and free will in a much more interesting way.

    Westworld felt like it wanted to have it both ways – an AI that knows all the outcomes except the ones it needs to not know so that the plot can play out how they want it to – and I felt that the whole show was treated the same way, you could really feel the writers’ hands in terms of how much it told us and how much we were in the dark, so a lot of it felt forced and artifical to me.

    Contrast that to season one where the mystery aspects were handled so deftly and it feels like the show has fallen a long way. And I say that as someone who also liked season two!

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27698

    (That bit with the giant robot smashing through the wall was good though.)

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27721

    Another thing I noticed, and that was only reinforced by whatshisname, Veronica’s Mars’ dad, showing up is that this season of Westworld was just as much a capstone to the themes and ideas of Person of Interest – two artifical intelligences warring, one trying to control the future and the other trying to set it free. Even Serac turning out to be the AI’s puppet is an idea directly lifted from Person of Interest. Which is fine, I mean, it’s all Nolan’s creations and it feels a bit like he tied one to the other here discreetly – change a few details and you can almost imagine that the world of Westworld is the future of Person of Interest’s world.

    Oh damn, nice catch… I completely forgot about PoI and Nolan jr’s involvement. I guess the re-use of their favorite themes over and over is a Nolan Family thing =P

    Shit, maybe that’s why I liked this season so much… now I feel like I got somewhat incepted… u_u

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27773

    I can’t remember if you watched Devs yet Christian, but I think part of the problem for me may have been that I watched that immediately before season three of Westworld, and it dealt with similar ideas around AI and predestination and free will in a much more interesting way.

    Fair enough! I haven’t watched it yet, and am very much looking forward to it.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27851

    Devs is worth the watch, Christian.

    I think the thing with Westworld Season 3 for me was that I just didn’t have any sympathy for Dolores and that made the narrative telling hard to land.  I liked Maeve, Caleb, Arnold/Bernard et all but Dolores was the kind of the “main character” this season and because her motives where obfuscated I never developed any sympathy for her at the point when the show wanted me to.  Similar I suppose to William’s journey.

    I think it is great high-budget television, and I loved the future aesthetic, but it just wasn’t as intriguing or as compelling as the earlier seasons.

    I’m not done though.  I liked the teaser at the end and am curious as to how it will all wrap up (even if it feels a little like extending the plot for it’s own sake).  I like how the Man in Black next season appears to be more of a riff on Yul Bryners character from the original movie.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #27860

    Yeah, I think both your and Dave’s criticism are definitely fair enough, I can definitely see what you’re saying. And one of the things that bothered me a bit was that the mechanics of how the plot pitched the different hosts against each other didn’t quite work for me; turning Maeve against Dolores was too easy. It’s just one of those cases where I didn’t mind the weaknesses and enjoyed the strengths a lot.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27866

    turning Maeve against Dolores was too easy

    Yeah, and I thought it was a shame that a strong character like Maeve was under the villain’s thumb for so much of the season. Although she did have her moments.

    To be honest Thandie Newton is one of the main things I continue to love about the show (and not just because she’s beautiful) – like Ed Harris, she just seems to elevate every scene she’s in.

    And talking of Harris, that scene with the multiple Williams was another highpoint. I’d love more of that kind of low-key character stuff from this show (and less of the big end-of-the-world stuff) as I think that’s where it’s at its best.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #27910

    Another thing I noticed, and that was only reinforced by whatshisname, Veronica’s Mars’ dad, showing up is that this season of Westworld was just as much a capstone to the themes and ideas of Person of Interest – two artifical intelligences warring, one trying to control the future and the other trying to set it free. Even Serac turning out to be the AI’s puppet is an idea directly lifted from Person of Interest. Which is fine, I mean, it’s all Nolan’s creations and it feels a bit like he tied one to the other here discreetly – change a few details and you can almost imagine that the world of Westworld is the future of Person of Interest’s world.

    Oh damn, nice catch… I completely forgot about PoI and Nolan jr’s involvement. I guess the re-use of their favorite themes over and over is a Nolan Family thing =P

    Shit, maybe that’s why I liked this season so much… now I feel like I got somewhat incepted… u_u

    Person of Interest is one of my favorite shows. What I truly love about it is the way the show grew and evolved. And it did so quite organically.

    PoI looked at AI on the macro level (ASI such as The Machine and Samaritan) while WW explores AI on a more personal scale.

    I personally think PoI is the better show, though.

  • #27926

    Another thing I noticed, and that was only reinforced by whatshisname, Veronica’s Mars’ dad,

    https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0170186/ He was great in POI, btw.

    showing up is that this season of Westworld was just as much a capstone to the themes and ideas of Person of Interest – two artifical intelligences warring, one trying to control the future and the other trying to set it free. Even Serac turning out to be the AI’s puppet is an idea directly lifted from Person of Interest. Which is fine, I mean, it’s all Nolan’s creations and it feels a bit like he tied one to the other here discreetly – change a few details and you can almost imagine that the world of Westworld is the future of Person of Interest’s world.

    I noticed that too and actually thought the same thing

    • This reply was modified 4 years, 6 months ago by Rocket.
    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #27929

    And talking of Harris, that scene with the multiple Williams was another highpoint. I’d love more of that kind of low-key character stuff from this show (and less of the big end-of-the-world stuff) as I think that’s where it’s at its best.

    this was one of the highlights of the season in my opinion. Only regret was Jimmy Simpson had less to do than I would have liked.

     

    Yeah, and I thought it was a shame that a strong character like Maeve was under the villain’s thumb for so much of the season. Although she did have her moments.

    this may be a weak comparison but Serac having control of Maeve’s pearl is a bit like Astra having Constantine’s coin in Legends of Tomorrow. The great thing is Maeve was able to rise above when she needed to at the end.

Viewing 83 replies - 1 through 83 (of 83 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Skip to toolbar