The Trades Thread: collected editions discussion

Home » Forums » Comics talk » The Trades Thread: collected editions discussion

Author
Topic
#69908

Are you tired of reading comics in short, monthly instalments?

Do you yearn for nice, smart books with spines, dustjackets and no ads?

Are you willing to pay ridiculously inflated prices for hardcover reprints of comics you already own in three different editions, just because the page size in the new version is ½” bigger?

Then this is the thread for you!

Viewing 100 replies - 501 through 600 (of 1,126 total)
Author
Replies
  • #98455

    Looking forward to it. Hopefully they’ll update the contents a bit before it comes out, or Uncanny X-Men Annual 10 remains uncollected. I know it’s in one of the New Mutant books, but it seems strange not to have it in the Uncanny omnibus series.

    According to Omar, it’ll be in Uncanny X-Men Omnibus 6.

  • #98464

    Vol 6? But, that’s basically what the Mutant Massacre Omnibus is already. Weird editorial decision. I think I draw the line at double dipping Omnibuses.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #98467

    Same here, it feels especially low to me, even for Marvel.

  • #98795

    Omniwatch

    Previews info say:

    – Classic New Warriors 2 – bumped to 5 Oct

    -:Peter David X-Factor 2 – to 1 Nov

    – Gerry Duggan Savage Avengers – still 1 Nov, might be one to bag as it’ll probably never get reprinted.

    Amazon.com have these later still, will have to see.

    Batman No Man’s Land 2 still looks to be for 20 Sept

     

  • #98823

    Recent reads:

    Providence

    This was OK.  I suspect the text pieces enhance it further, but the font made those hard to read for me.

    Where the book excels is its depiction of the US post WW1.  It’s easy to forget about prohibition and what it represented in the US.  That strand of buried, and-not-so-buried, intolerane runs through the story.

    Garth Ennis Battle Action

    A seven story celebration of the Action, Ennis writes the set, with excellent art collaborators to back him up.

    Ennis writing war stories is a no-brainer.  All of these are excellent – nab it.

    Robin and Batman HC

    The only flaw here is that this should have been an OHC.

    That aside, where art partners are concerned, Nguyen is up with Sorrentino where Lemire is concerned.  Both artists on their own are excellent, but their work with Lemire tends to be that bit better still.

    This is a compact, three issue tale focuses on Robin in relation to Batman.  And it is a great little story that deserves attention.

    Rogue Sun Volume 1

    Part of the Massive-verse started by Kyle Higgins and friends, this is the first of the books in addition to Radiant Black.

    On the one hand, Dylan’s eventual destination of no longer being the arse he starts off as is probably assured. Even so, starting him off as a bullying slacker is a bold choice and, after the six issues collected here, I can’t say I like the character.  But I suspect some smart follow through based on how Radiant Black approached well known superhero concepts.

  • #98837

    Finally showed up on Amazon.
    HULK: MAESTRO BY PETER DAVID OMNIBUS Hardcover – April 25 2023
    Collecting HULK: FUTURE IMPERFECT #1-2, INCREDIBLE HULK (1968) #460-461, CAPTAIN MARVEL (1999) #27-30, SPIDER-MAN 2099 (2014) #9-10, FUTURE IMPERFECT #1-5, MAESTRO #1-5, MAESTRO: WAR AND PAX #1-5, MAESTRO: WORLD WAR M #1-5, EXILES (2001) #79-80, ABOMINATIONS #1-3, and material from HULK: BROKEN WORLDS #1 and SECRET WARS: BATTLEWORLD #4.

    and did we know about this?
    Snow Angels Library Edition Hardcover – March 7 2023
    Jeff Lemire & Jock
    Collects Snow Angels Volume 1 and Volume 2 in a deluxe, oversized hardcover edition.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #98838

    No! But I was certainly hoping for one for Snow Angels.  Great find!

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #98962

    Dealer Alert

    BooksEtc has Dark Knights of Steel Volume 1 going for £12.35

  • #99058

    Fantastic Four: Full Circle

    Finally got hold of this today, having keenly anticipated it for a while now. A brand new slim square hardcover OGN by Alex Ross (kind of similar to the DC Black Label larger format or the old 80s Marvel OGNs), featuring a new Fantastic Four adventure that nestles into the original Stan & Jack continuity.

    The first thing to say is that Ross’s art (which isn’t always to my tastes, especially the more static pinup stuff) looks incredible here. There are some great Kirby-influenced designs, slick and detailed linework, and vibrant/psychedelic colour palette choices. It all looks great.

    The writing is good, but not quite at the same level – partly I think because it’s consciously a homage to the past and so is a relatively simple adventure story without much depth or anything really unexpected.

    However, it does have the strengths of those Kirby era comics in that there are tons of ideas that come thick and fast, and all the sci-fi and fantasy concepts work really well visually.

    So it’s well worth a read, just don’t expect anything revolutionary from the writing.

    Plus the book just feels like a real quality package overall, down to the lovely endpapers and foldout dustjacket (with a potted origin story for the FF by Ross).

    This is one of the better Big Two books that I’ve read lately, and I wonder if it’s partly that there’s a bit more creative freedom and less editorial diktat with Marvel licensing-out their characters like this (the book is published by Abrams Comicarts). I wonder if it’s a route forwards for quality books from them in future.

    6 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99226

    While they have their flaws, SpeedyHen are offering Newburn Volume 1 for £10.97.  Good price for an eight issue trade.

    In other news, it is not on Image’s site nor on Previews.  Looks like Radiant Red Volume 1 was a phantom listing, so probably not coming 13 Sept.  Will be solicited at some point.

  • #99228

    While they have their flaws, SpeedyHen are offering Newburn Volume 1 for £10.97.  Good price for an eight issue trade.

    Nice find. I enjoyed this in singles and had been planning to grab the trade.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #99230

    Dealer Alert

    Couple of SpeedyHen preorders went active:

    Gideon Falls OHC2 – £23.61

    Die OHC – £33.51

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #99353

    Time For Lights Out HC

    I’ve been reading this over the last couple of weeks, a collection of Raymond Briggs’ final strips, poems and writing, published before his death and which I had been meaning to read for a while.

    It’s very much focused on his feelings at the end of his time: ageing, death and loneliness, interspersed with remembrances of his earlier years and important people in his life.

    While the subject matter can be heavy at times, it’s shot through with wit and warmth and an endearingly curmudgeonly take on the world, and as a result it’s both very funny and very moving – I found myself tearful several times while reading it.

    It also made me realise how relatively under-represented the viewpoints of the elderly are, and how refreshing it is to hear some no-bullshit, unsentimental but honest reflections on life from someone at the end of it.

    While the art is occasionally sketchy or unfinished (some sections towards the end feel like comic scripts without any art at all, while much of the book is plain prose or poetry without any art at all), there’s an ethereal and almost ghostly quality to it that suits the material.

    Well worth a read if you’ve ever been a fan, but not something to try and take in all in one sitting.

    5 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99423

    Dealer Alert

    BooksEtc have dropped Batman: One Dark Knight HC down to £14.58 (RRP £25)

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #99571

    My Seven To Eternity Deluxe Hardcover edition has been shipped from the Speedyhen. Played the long game on this one so that I could get that lovely Jerome Opena work in oversized hardcover. Hope it was worth the wait.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99576

    Same here, just before the old order expired too.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99586

    Same here! And with a £5-off code too. Should arrive tomorrow.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99609

    And what a thing of beauty it is.

    It’s even more huge than I expected. Absolute-sized pages, and look at the size of that spine!

    Looking forward to cracking this open.

    5 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99617

    Tuesday for me, which works perfectly.

  • #99624

    Hit Me v.1 TPB

    I bought this AWA collection on a whim after hearing some good things about it, and I thought it was a pretty good read.

    It’s a crime/noir story that’s given a fresh twist by being set against the backdrop of the BDSM sex trade, with a heroine who’s a pain specialist that gets mixed up in a tangled criminal plot.

    Both the writing and art are pretty straightforward but tell the story well, and there’s a genuine feeling of edge to some of it but without it ever feeling too exploitative or gratuitous, despite a lot of fairly adult content. I think that’s because it handles all that stuff in a fairly matter-of-fact and honest way, rather than going for the titillating slick Hollywood version.

    Overall, reminded me a bit of the recent Gun Honey from Titan in that it’s a fun pulp-y read with a decent female lead and a nice pace to the whole thing, which is entertaining throughout even if it doesn’t altogether avoid some of the clichés that come with this kind of story.

    For a five issue trade at under a tenner it’s also pretty good value.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99628

    And what a thing of beauty it is.

    It’s even more huge than I expected. Absolute-sized pages, and look at the size of that spine!

    Looking forward to cracking this open.

    That’ll look great next to my two Fear Agent Library Editions 👍🏼

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99631

    Hit Me v.1 TPB
    I bought this AWA collection on a whim after hearing some good things about it, and I thought it was a pretty good read.

    I read one of Christa Faust’s prose novels (MONEY SHOT) 10 years ago and really enjoyed her crime-noir sensibilities. I may have to seek this one out, while I’m picking up SEVEN TO ETERNITY.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99632

    Plus Tokyo Ghost, Low, Black Science, Deadly Class, Death Or Glory….

    Talking of Remender hardbacks, from Blackwell-fishing:

    – Deadly Class OHC4 – April 2023

    – The Scumbag OHC – June 2023

    Other items of note:

    – Bone Orchard Mythos: Ten Thousand Black Feathers HC – May 2023

    – The Good Asian: 1936 Edition – June 2023

    – Usagi Yojimbo: The Green Dragon – Feb 2023

  • #99633

    I read one of Christa Faust’s prose novels (MONEY SHOT) 10 years ago and really enjoyed her crime-noir sensibilities. I may have to seek this one out, while I’m picking up SEVEN TO ETERNITY.

    It’s only $9.99 for a five-issue trade, so well worth a punt.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #99634

    Plus Tokyo Ghost, Low, Black Science, Deadly Class, Death Or Glory….

    I’m not a Remender completing, but I do have the Tokyo Ghost and Death Or Glory OHCs and they’re very nice books indeed.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #99635

    There’s an Omnibus of Unbeatable Squirrel Girl out in Feb: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Unbeatable-Squirrel-Girl-Omnibus/dp/1302950614

    Collects all 58 issues, plus The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl Beats Up the Marvel Universe OGN.

  • #99636

    I actually get a lot of Remender’s work in singles, so most it sits in a long box or two in my garage. Or at least I used to until the ending of Black Science soured me on him. I still check out his work, but a lot more cautiously than I did previously. Opena’s art is the main reason I got these few in oversized hardcover.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #99637

    So long as the price for the big OHC version remains cheaper  than buying the paperbacks, I consider it a worthwhile gamble on Remender’s stuff but that might not be so the way things are going.

    In other hardback news:

    – The Amazing Screw-On Head and Other Stories got a LE size edition end of July that I missed.

    – There’s a LE sized hardback collection of Mignola’s trio of Mr Higgins stories due December.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #99810

    Liam Sharp’s Starhenge needs a bit of support for its March 2023 deluxe HC.  Preorders are needed.

    Blackwell’s have it for £23.75 right now.  Jan 2023 might see a few quid cheaper offer from SpeedyHen but, with the way things are with inflation, Blackwell’s offer might end up better than expected.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #99985

    I’ve almost completed my Sandman trades. Just need volumes 11 and 12 to complete it then try and read everything by Christmas. Still actively waiting for the first volume of Reckless and volumes of Fatale to be available at my local bookstore.

  • #99987

    Still actively waiting for the first volume of Reckless and volumes of Fatale to be available at my local bookstore.

    Can you ask them to order them in? They’re well worth reading.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #99991

    What happened with the Fatale Deluxe Edition reprints? I thought they were going to happen shortly after the Criminal HC reprints.

    I haven’t seen or heard anything since.
    Sure would be nice.

  • #99992

    I don’t remember hearing that Fatale reprints were coming. I think Brubaker has said that reprints are very unlikely on the OHCs in general.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #99993

    Yeah, I don’t recall seeing talk of that.  The production costs were already major and it sounds like they are going up.

    Talking of costs going up, I’ll be surprised if there isn’t another price rise of US trades due to the kamiKwasi budget tanking the pound.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #100001

    Talking of costs going up, I’ll be surprised if there isn’t another price rise of US trades due to the kamiKwasi budget tanking the pound.

    Yep, seems very likely.

    Comic books aren’t the most important things in life, admittedly, and obviously even things like food and basic heating are a worry for some people at the moment. But it is still a bit of a pisser that after the hikes of Brexit and the weakening of the pound overall over the past 15 years, the tories keep making such an expensive hobby even pricier.

    (Those early-2000s days where it was more like two dollars to the pound seem like very long ago now.)

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #100003

    Solution: Buy more Cinebook, Titan, Rebellion and Panini trades? I kind of already do.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #100017

    I’m probably going to but it typically has about a few months wait depending on its availability on their main branch. I do have friend of the devil. So I’m waiting to buy the first Reckless book so I can read it.  Still missing a few books for my Brubaker/Philips collection.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #100052

    Dealer Alert

    Batman: Curse of the White Knight OHC now at BooksEtc for £23.75.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #100096

    Dealer Alert

    Batman: Curse of the White Knight OHC now at BooksEtc for £23.75.

    £22.26 now!

  • #100098

    Balls.  Still, nabbed other bargains via SpeedyHen that more than balance it out.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #100101

    Holy shit – if you want Batman: No Man’s Land Omnibus Volume 2 get your arse to SpeedyHen and nab it quick for £57.99

    Just received my copy and the RRP on it was $150! Volume 1 was the more usual $125.

    Looks like it is time for me to stop buying the big DC omnibuses now.

  • #100102

    Yeah for me I think the £50 mark is a bit of a mental barrier. Time was that you could nab all these big books for £40-£45ish but now that they’re approaching £60 the value isn’t there for me.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #100136

    And, in an instant last night, the RRP for Transformers Phase Three Volume 3 OHC jumped from £50 to £55!

    Er, yeah, OK, will see what happens but I don’t care that much about this one.

    Also, a load of trades look to be bumped to late Oct or Nov, likely see knock-on impacts further on down the line.

  • #100139

    Finally this is in my hands!

    I’ve always enjoyed these Artist Edition giant-sized reprints of original art over the years, but Todd McFarlane’s Spidey has always been a bit of a holy grail for me. And now it’s here, it doesn’t disappoint. There are some fantastic pages in here to pore over.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #100146

    Ouch. RRP $125 Marvel omnibus now is £119! It was £104.50.  That places getting these at the £65 mark as the best price.

    Some stuff I will probably bite the bullet on – Peter David X-Factor, classic Claremont X-Men, Millar and Hitch’s FF but other stuff? Probably not, unless I started a series and there’s a concluding volume.

    Not everything has been affected yet, might be different distribution chains are mitigating it.

  • #100148

    Order now, before they’re £200!

  • #100151

    Well, at that point it’s easy, no sale!

  • #100294

    3DA1AA30-0FB6-4186-9F91-C93AA9E783D8

    Got my 3W3M subscriber rewards package today. A lovely oversized paperback collection of most of the first year’s material (sourcebook and comics). Two exclusive signed prints (Hickman, Huddleston, del Mundo). And a metal members only card (to be fair, not sure what the point of this is, but it’s nicely done).

    The hardcover version of this book was even more beautiful, but limited to the super expensive subscriber tier. I believe that a follow on printing of the TPB will be released for purchase soonish.

    I didn’t know they were going to do physical rewards when I signed up last year, so this was a nice surprise. I was happy that I subscribed anyway, but this was the proverbial icing on the cake.

    4 users thanked author for this post.
  • #100913

    I finally got around to reading the latest Blacksad – All Fall Down pt 1.

    Absolutely gorgeous, as ever. Nice noiry story and being a two parter, it has more room to breathe and build up.

    I did find I kept getting pulled out of the story though, by overt references to the species of characters. It’s been a couple of years since I last read any of Blacksad, but I could have sworn the various species were only referred to euphemistically (Blacksad was a “cat” in the slang sense) and used as metaphor and short hand to personality (the white suprematists were all fully white animals, mixed race characters had patches of coloured fur, Weekly “ferrets out” news etc). And the latter is still true here, but then you’ve got multiple instances of characters being straight up called “bat”, “gull”, “gator” etc. It’s feels a bit artless and on the nose. The difference between a story about “real” people who happen to be depicted as animals and something like Zootopia, where they’re all consciously different species.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #100969

    Dealer Alert

    Ascender OHC preorder now active at SpeedyHen for £28.73

  • #101015

    Curse Words

    I have to admit to being ambivalent on this as I found the first of Soule’s original series I read, Letter 44, to start well but reduced over time.  It ended OK but that was about it.

    Still, just over £30 for a 28 issue, five trades collection, as a standard hardback, is quite the value proposition.  It’s aides by Soule’s artistic collaborator, Rysn Browne.  I liked God Hates Astronauts.  It didn’t draw me back but it was good, with a distinctive sense of style.

    The two go together well here.  The story combines dimension hopping and time travel and magic and the combination works.  It also acts as a deconstruction of the standard hero badass. You know the type, a violent know-it-all who wibs every fight.  Sent to Earth to destroy it, Wizord finds himself met with an unexpected opportunity he never saw coming.

    What’s notable about this is Soule doesn’t instantly redeem Wizord from his violent, psychopath past.  Instead, he’s a flawed character up until the end.

    There’s more to it of course, but those pieces work better without revealing them.  The only two parts that did not work are the new epilogue issue.  That falls pretty flat.  The second is how Soule renders Jacques Zacques’ french accent – it’s terrible.

    Overall, this was a well paced and executed series that also knew when to stop.  In Browne, Soule has an excellent collaborator and I’ll likely give their next series, Eight Billion Genies, a go when the trade comes out next year.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #101017

    IMMORTAL HULK OMNIBUS Hardcover – July 4 2023 – click for cover

    The entirety of Al Ewing’s Hulk masterpiece, called one of the greatest comic books of all time, collected in an omnibus!
    COLLECTING: Immortal Hulk (2018) 1-50, Immortal Hulk: The Best Defense (2018) 1, Defenders: The Best Defense (2018) 1, Absolute Carnage: Immortal Hulk (2019) 1, Immortal Hulk (2020) 0, Immortal She-Hulk (2020) 1, King in Black: Immortal Hulk (2020) 1, Immortal Hulk: Time of Monsters (2021) 1 (A story), material from Avengers (2018) 684
    Print length 1592 pages
    ISBN-10 1302949977
    ISBN-13 978-1302949976

    I guess I’ll go this route, but that is a big book.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #101018

    Yep. Same size or possibly a bit bigger than the War of the Realms Omnibus and that was a monster.  Practically I tend to go with 1350 as the upper limit for page count.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #101033

    Actually the numbers are starting to sink in. 1592 pages?

    Hellblazer (Ennis) is 1352
    Who’s Who vol. 1 is 1320, vol. 2 (Nov. 29th) is 1216
    LSH 5 Years later vol. 1 is 1424, vol. 2 is 1328

    Those are monsters.
    I get it, it’s a better sell for an all-in-one Ennis Hellblazer.

    Planetary, Authority, Gotham Central, all under 1000 pages and very nice.
    This should really be the target.

    LSH 5 Years Later could’ve been 3 volumes instead of 2.
    Flip side of that is it may not have happened at all if someone said no to 3.
    Have to admit it would be a hard job to decide this stuff. Things have to sell in the end.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #101053

    One of the biggest I have is the Invisibles omni, and that’s 1536 pages. So this is going to be in that ballpark.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #101291

    Enjoyed this just as much in TPB as I did in singles.

    It all hangs together really nicely, with Zeb Wells providing a solid mix of superhero stuff, crime drama and soap-opera subplots, all with a perfect Peter Parker voice. And JR jr’s art looks great.

    Vintage Spidey.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #101324

    Are you double dipping on it Dave, or have you dropped the singles?

  • #101325

    Still buying in monthlies – but I tend to sell on pretty much all my singles these days and rebuy anything I want to keep in trade.

    (Singles are a massive faff to store, find, look after etc. so the only ones I tend to have are ones that aren’t collected anywhere.)

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #101474

    Pair of recent reads:

    Joy Operations

    A new creator owned book from Bendis, this was a fun read.  It’s definitely a book boosted by its art.

    Weaknesses are the future world isn’t that well described, the world building is weak.  Joy is your standard security bad ass who, despite Bendis’ best efforts, doesn’t develop much as the story goes on.  For a five-issue paperback, it’s overpriced at a RRP of £22.99.  A few quid less woukd encourage more experimental buys.

    Still, I’ve wanted Bendis to get back to creator owned work for a long time.  In that respect, this is good to see, despite not being his best work.

    Norse Mythology Volume 2

    There’s not much to say about this one for the best reasons: Excellent writing and art, top notch production values on the hardback.  That’s pretty much it.

  • #101515

    Dealer Alert

    Monstress OHC2 now available to preorder at SpeedyHen for £28.73

    Release date changes from 28 December to 13 December.

  • #101568

    Other stuff at SpeedyHen is Little Monsters Volume 1 and Farmhand Volume 4.

    Both are going for £10.97. Will they stay at that in the world of wet lettuce economics? Dunno.

    Edit – talking of volatile prices, Hellions OHC at BooksEtc for £37.75

    https://www.booksetc.co.uk/books/view/-9781302933722

  • #101741

    I was expecting a trio of old SpeedyHen orders, nabbed with the £5 off code, to expire.  Instead they despatched in the last day! On the way I have:

    – Hellboy: The Silver Lantern Club

    – Hellboy: The Bones of Giants

    – The Rise and Fall of the Trigan Empire Volume IV

    Also – Dealer Alert

    The Out – a new 2000AD story from Abnett and Harrison is at BooksEtc for £12.92

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #101744

    Also – Dealer Alert The Out – a new 2000AD story from Abnett and Harrison is at BooksEtc for £12.92

    Great find. That’s been recommended here and I was hoping to find a decent deal on the collection.

  • #101745

    I’ve been keeping a close eye on it.

    Turns out Blackwells is a really good indicator of when stuff will become available.  They had copies a day or so ago.  That was my cue to keep checking BooksEtc for when they had copies.

    Meanwhile SpeedyHen’s pricing algorithm has another burp increase on Marvel omnibuses, but it’s not been matched elsewhere so could be a quirk.

    SH remain the best for Image paperbacks if you wait until release day.  Blackwells can be very good too.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #101746

    It looks like The Out is now sold out at Books Etc, but I did a further search and found it on FP.com for just over £10 plus shipping. By combining it with some other orders it worked out as the slightly better deal.

  • #101747

    !? Damn, that was fast.

  • #102249

    Recent reads:

    Farmhand Volume 4

    It’s great to have this series back.  Hopefully all the way through to its conclusion, though that is where some Image series fall down. (Redneck and Copperhead I’m looking at you.)

    This progresses the story quite a bit, especially if Guillory sticks with the final page cliffhanger.

    Little Monsters Volume 1

    Pary of me says wait for the OHC but the prices are going that might be too high.  In any case this is another great book from Lemire-Nguyen.

    With a mostly monochrome art style, punctuated by some very careful use of colour, Lemire unfurls a future, horror dystopia with nods to both climate change and covid.

    Radiant Black Volume 3

    This continues to be one of the best independent superhero books going.  It also has a wry take on superheroes, with one villain being a Crypto Bro set-up flogging NFTs!

    Newburn Volume 1

    It would be easy but totally unfair to say Jacob Phillips had it made for working in comics.  If anything the shadow cast by his father probably made it harder for him. What he shows here is that he has his oen style and it is one very suited to crime stories.

    At the same time Zdarsky takes the more unusual move of telling mostly complete single issue stories.  But each adds to an overall picture and pays off at the end.

    For all he’s been cropping up everywhere I haven’t read Zdarsky before.  Based on this? I like what he does.  It all flows well and I’ll probably check out his other Image work.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #102251

    For all he’s been cropping up everywhere I haven’t read Zdarsky before.  Based on this? I like what he does.

    He’s very good, his run on Daredevil has been excellent and I’ll be catching up on his batman stuff.

  • #102252

    Daredevil I’m stacking up on the OHCs.

  • #102253

    Yeah, his Daredevil is good and his Batman run is shaping up quite nicely. I don’t love everything he’s done but when he’s good he’s very solid.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #102469

    Marvel have just announced a Sigil Omnibus. I literally have no words :unsure:

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #102470

    Info’s proving a bit elusive, got a link to it Vik?

    I liked the one-time revival Carey did, take it you recommend the original run?

  • #102471

    I just saw it on Near Mint Condition’s Facebook page, Ben.

    I actually read a lot of CrossGen’s stuff as they originally came out. I was a big fan of most of the creators at the time (Marz, Dixon, Waid, Perez, Pelletier, Guice, even Greg Land before he became so obvious about his photo shopping, …). They were also the first company to really pursue digital as an option. Ground breaking.

    But, when they crashed and burned, most of their series just stopped inconclusively.

    From what little I read of Sigil it wasn’t particularly captivating. It was one of the core 4 launch books in their universe, and as such had Mark Alessi’s fingerprints on it much more than some of their later books. There’s a reason he had to set up his own comics company in order to publish this stuff. It’s not bad. A high action sci-fi title a la Star Wars. But, it’s not going to blow anyone away either.

    So, all in all, I’m a bit flabbergasted that Marvel have chosen to publish a premium high end collected edition of this series. I can’t imagine there’s a market for this out there.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #102472

    I think a lot of it comes down to personal taste and the nostalgia aspect. I think we all have our guilty pleasures and runs that we have a soft spot for even when we know they’re not objectively great – usually because they hit us just at the right time as young readers.

    (For me personally I have the McFarlane adjectiveless Spider-Man omnibus and loads of early-era Spawn HCs on my shelf.)

    As we get older the sweet spot for those nostalgia-oriented collections gets later, and we get to the point where they’re collecting stuff that we probably already recognised as not great at the time. But for some people, those Crossgen books will be their sweet spot.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #102473

    That’s fair. I certainly have a bunch of objectively rubbish (1990’s bollocks, I think I called them) books in my collection purely for nostalgia.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #102474

    Ah, Omar hasn’t yet put the video out then.

    Marvel are seriously ramping up the Omnibuses and not with just older material either.  There’s a Saladin Ahmed Miles Morales omnibus set for August 2023.

  • #102475

    I think a lot of it comes down to personal taste and the nostalgia aspect. I think we all have our guilty pleasures and runs that we have a soft spot for even when we know they’re not objectively great – usually because they hit us just at the right time as young readers.

    ‘The Golden Age of Comics is 12’ is the quote I always liked (can’t remember who said it, some comics writer on a podcast).

    There’s a lot of truth in that, at that age I would pick up just about anything I could get my hands on, from Marvel UK reprints to very spottily distributed US books. A lot of it is not very good but still holds a special place in my affections.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #102532

    Dealer Alert

    Zdarsky Daredevil OHC3 going for £24.96 at BooksEtc.

    https://www.booksetc.co.uk/books/view/-9781302945114

  • #102538

    Miracleman omnibus is on the way from Speedyhen! Was happy to get this one for sub-£50.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #102543

    That was written by JB Grover, right?

  • #102589

    Curt Vile wrote it.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #102766

    Dealer Alert

    The World of Black Hammer: Library Edition Volume 4

    Books Etc – £27.58

    https://www.booksetc.co.uk/books/view/-9781506726014

  • #102852

    I don’t pick up many of these Marvel Epic Collections but I grabbed this one, as it means that all of Ann Nocenti’s Daredevil run is finally collected in trade!

    Feels like there should really be a nice big fat omnibus of this run at some point though. It deserves it.

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #102854

    How large is it / number of issues?

    Sometimes Marvel does Omnibus then Epics, but it also can go the other way I think.

  • #102855

    It collects #234-#252, so a pretty decent chunk.

    (I already have the Epics covering the rest of Nocenti’s run.)

  • #102857

    If there’s 2-3 Epics there probably will be an Omnibus eventually.

  • #102863

    It’s closer to 3-4 Epics. The entire Nocenti run is #236-#291 (with a couple of non-Nocenti issues sprinkled throughout), so maybe at the very outside of the range of a typical Marvel omnibus.

    Although if they’re doing Immortal Hulk in a single volume then they could probably manage this if they really wanted to.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    Ben
  • #102866

    They’re now doing 50-60 issue Omnibuses, so could happen.

  • #102917

    I got Young Justice Book Six today. Huzzah! I’m not going to have chance to read it for a while, but it’s nice to have the end of the series (I’ve not checked, but I assume they have actually included everything to finish it off, although you know DC) and I genuinely didn’t think they were going to. On the other hand though, it’s got a markedly different paper quality to every other volume in the series. Very matte and coarse paper, almost of the type DC used to use in their trades back in the 90 to mid-00s. Hopefully it won’t yellow as much as those ones did.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #102926

    Dealer Alert

    Usagi Yojimbo: Volume 4: Crossroads

    At BooksEtc for £10.31

    https://www.booksetc.co.uk/books/view/-9781684059102

  • #103050

    Dealer Alert

    Tales from Harrow County Library Edition Volume 1 at BooksEtc for £22.36

    https://www.booksetc.co.uk/books/view/-9781506722764

    SpeedyHen preorder active for Dark Nights: Metal Omnibus for £47.32:

    https://www.speedyhen.com/Product/Scott-Snyder/Dark-Nights-Metal-Omnibus/27974168

    Price is likely to go up so move fast. BooksEtc has the RRP now at £136!

  • #103052

    Another good deal I just saw – the Brubaker/Phillips Sleeper Omnibus 2022 reprint is available to order on Speedyhen for £36.70, which is pretty great for an omni of that size these days.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #103053

    Get the preorder in quick, think they’ll both go way up.

  • #103056

    Don’t sleep on Sleeper!

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #103057

    the Brubaker/Phillips Sleeper Omnibus 2022 reprint is available to order on Speedyhen for £36.70,

    Amazon has it for $90, so the Speedyhen offer is a GREAT deal!

    2 users thanked author for this post.
  • #103063

    Other SpeedyHen preorders worth nabbing:

    Superman: Birthright OHC  – RRP will be going up to £45 so £26.09 is a good price.

    Suicide Squad: Blaze OHC (probably) RRP will be going up to £26 so can be bagged for £14.27

    Batman: Detective Comics: Shadow of the Bat HC – RRP looks to go up to £36, can be bagged for £21.38

  • #103249

    Dealer Alert

    Superman: Son of Kal-El Volume 2 at BooksEtc for £12.09

    https://www.booksetc.co.uk/books/view/-9781779517388

    1 user thanked author for this post.
  • #103404

    The Out TPB

    After hearing multiple recommendations here and elsewhere when this was first coming out in the individual 2000AD progs, I checked out this new collection. And I really enjoyed it – one of the best strips I’ve read from 2000AD in a long while, and one which surprises you with some of the turns it takes.

    What starts out as quite a light knockabout yarn ends up delivering some surprisingly emotional and thoughtful moments which hit harder than you might expect.

    And the art is really vivid and original and drives the story in a lot of ways, rather than just serving it.

    While it’s quite a different type of story, I was reminded of Halo Jones at times by the scope of the book and the way it presents everything from the viewpoint of its lead character as she makes her way through the universe.

    A really good read and I’ll look forward to more.

    4 users thanked author for this post.
  • #103413

    The Out is brilliant. Absolutely stunning piece of work, with moments of serene beauty and abject horror. Flat out brilliant.

    Glad you enjoyed it too, Dave!

    3 users thanked author for this post.
  • #103419

    While it’s quite a different type of story, I was reminded of Halo Jones at times by the scope of the book and the way it presents everything from the viewpoint of its lead character as she makes her way through the universe.

    Yeah it evokes Halo Jones because we have a female lead in a sci-fi story and the fact that neither are on any real quest, they are just trying to get by day to day.

    Both those elements are pretty rare in comics which drives comparison but in all other aspects they are very different.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
Viewing 100 replies - 501 through 600 (of 1,126 total)

This topic is temporarily locked.

Skip to toolbar