Few things:
These “What if?” or “Elseworlds” stories about alternate events of a given known story usually never end well. It might be on purpose to just say that the original written story was the best one and we got it right the first time. And it’s not just comics. The Star Trek “Strange New Worlds” had an alternate reality episode where Pike remained captain and how he handled the Romulan ship in “The Balance of Terror”. Stephen King’s story about time travel and preventing the JFK assassination ended up with some US conservative movement and George Wallace got in the White House and started WW3. (I’d like to think that if Oswald didn’t do anything, the Vietnam situation would never have escalated, the Beatles would have played the WH, the 60s would have been different etc. but not WW3)
It seems there is no “What if?” story where in the alternate reality things turned out better.
——————
DC and Marvel have put out a few crossover stories – I Always wondered about these Marvel v DC character but then it turns out it’s really one character fighting their analogue counterpart. I always wanted a Superman vs. Gladiator but it was John Byrne who developed Gladiator’s powers and feats as more telekinetic etc. instead of just brute strength. Then years later when he went to DC and was given the Superman reboot, Superman’s powers and his picking up huge oversized structures were the same. The match up would just be a battle of analogues. Supreme is just a thinly veiled you know who…
—————
Seeing the old X Factor of the original 5 X-men compared to them from 1963 just shows how altered characters get to remain relevant. Beast, Angel to Archangel, Marvel Girl to Phoenix, Iceman no longer looking like a snowman. Then in the X titles how Psylocke originally was in her pink outfit and butterfly aura, the Siege Perilous (or Plot Device) and how she was redone in this sexy Asian body with a psychic knife and an Elektra outfit but in blue. It made her more noticeable though. So many other examples not just Marvel.
End of ramble… 🤣
-
This reply was modified 1 month, 1 week ago by
Al-x.